Reviews


Film Review: After Earth

Guided by his injured father, a cadet crosses a hostile planet to retrieve a spaceship beacon in a somber, soapy, only occasionally effective sci-fi adventure.

-By Daniel Eagan


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1377848-After-Earth-Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

It's a cruel world out there for superstar Will Smith and his son Jaden in After Earth, this month's dystopian sci-fi morality tale. Audiences aren't likely to be kind to this slow, simplistic movie, no matter how hard director M. Night Shyamalan tries to pump up the story.

A thousand years in the future, humans have evacuated a polluted, uninhabitable Earth for a desert colony besieged by killer "Ursa" aliens who prey on "fear" pheromones. Prime Commander Cypher Raige (Will Smith) has conquered his fear, making him invisible to the aliens. Ranger cadets practice his "ghosting" technique, hoping to kill the Ursas before they wipe out humanity.

The cold, enigmatic Cypher has a troubled relationship with his son Kitai (Jaden Smith), a failed Ranger with daddy issues and residual guilt over the alien murder of his sister Senshi (Zoë Isabella Kravitz). Several dull and awkward scenes place Cypher, Kitai and a caged Ursa on a space flight to a planet used for training exercises.

An asteroid storm destroys the spaceship, which crashes onto the surface of Earth. The Ursa escapes. Kitai and Cypher are the only human survivors, but with his leg broken and femoral artery torn, Cypher is confined to the remains of the cockpit. A space beacon will help rescue them, but it's some 60 miles away. It's up to the terrified Kitai to find and ignite the beacon.

Guided by Cypher, who is watching by camera, Kitai wanders across a rain forest, off a cliff, down a river, and into a cave, encountering baboons, a giant hawk, mutated tigers, a poisonous leech and other indifferently rendered CG creatures. Cypher can offer warnings and advice, but this is Kitai's game to win or lose.

Will Smith may as well have said, "Here's my son, make him a star." Take away the actor's best qualities—his verbal dexterity, his outsized personality—then make him immobile, and After Earth becomes a Will Smith vehicle in name only.

Jaden Smith has screen presence, but he is not an accomplished actor, no matter how hard his father wills it. His dialogue is unintelligible at times, and he seems limited to a handful of poses and emotional responses. Carrying a big-budget movie by himself at this stage in his career is asking too much.

After Earth is too blunt, too insistent in both content and technique to be called metaphorical. Will Smith helped produce, and is responsible for the story, so it's hard to place all the blame on Shyamalan and co-writer Gary Whitta ( The Book of Eli) for After Earth's plodding pace and kindergarten life lessons.

But Shyamalan needs to update his style, which right now seems based on old "Twilight Zone" episodes. He's like a stage hypnotist who keeps insisting, "Look out, something scary is going to happen." Computer warning screens, verbal and visual countdowns, speeches about tension and sweating, another foreboding James Newton Howard score: Shyamalan all but drags you by the hand to the film's few scares and jolts.

After Earth is by no means the disaster that The Last Airbender was. It's just not very much fun to watch.


Film Review: After Earth

Guided by his injured father, a cadet crosses a hostile planet to retrieve a spaceship beacon in a somber, soapy, only occasionally effective sci-fi adventure.

May 30, 2013

-By Daniel Eagan


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1377848-After-Earth-Md.jpg

It's a cruel world out there for superstar Will Smith and his son Jaden in After Earth, this month's dystopian sci-fi morality tale. Audiences aren't likely to be kind to this slow, simplistic movie, no matter how hard director M. Night Shyamalan tries to pump up the story.

A thousand years in the future, humans have evacuated a polluted, uninhabitable Earth for a desert colony besieged by killer "Ursa" aliens who prey on "fear" pheromones. Prime Commander Cypher Raige (Will Smith) has conquered his fear, making him invisible to the aliens. Ranger cadets practice his "ghosting" technique, hoping to kill the Ursas before they wipe out humanity.

The cold, enigmatic Cypher has a troubled relationship with his son Kitai (Jaden Smith), a failed Ranger with daddy issues and residual guilt over the alien murder of his sister Senshi (Zoë Isabella Kravitz). Several dull and awkward scenes place Cypher, Kitai and a caged Ursa on a space flight to a planet used for training exercises.

An asteroid storm destroys the spaceship, which crashes onto the surface of Earth. The Ursa escapes. Kitai and Cypher are the only human survivors, but with his leg broken and femoral artery torn, Cypher is confined to the remains of the cockpit. A space beacon will help rescue them, but it's some 60 miles away. It's up to the terrified Kitai to find and ignite the beacon.

Guided by Cypher, who is watching by camera, Kitai wanders across a rain forest, off a cliff, down a river, and into a cave, encountering baboons, a giant hawk, mutated tigers, a poisonous leech and other indifferently rendered CG creatures. Cypher can offer warnings and advice, but this is Kitai's game to win or lose.

Will Smith may as well have said, "Here's my son, make him a star." Take away the actor's best qualities—his verbal dexterity, his outsized personality—then make him immobile, and After Earth becomes a Will Smith vehicle in name only.

Jaden Smith has screen presence, but he is not an accomplished actor, no matter how hard his father wills it. His dialogue is unintelligible at times, and he seems limited to a handful of poses and emotional responses. Carrying a big-budget movie by himself at this stage in his career is asking too much.

After Earth is too blunt, too insistent in both content and technique to be called metaphorical. Will Smith helped produce, and is responsible for the story, so it's hard to place all the blame on Shyamalan and co-writer Gary Whitta (The Book of Eli) for After Earth's plodding pace and kindergarten life lessons.

But Shyamalan needs to update his style, which right now seems based on old "Twilight Zone" episodes. He's like a stage hypnotist who keeps insisting, "Look out, something scary is going to happen." Computer warning screens, verbal and visual countdowns, speeches about tension and sweating, another foreboding James Newton Howard score: Shyamalan all but drags you by the hand to the film's few scares and jolts.

After Earth is by no means the disaster that The Last Airbender was. It's just not very much fun to watch.

ADVERTISEMENT



REVIEWS

Dawn of the Apes review
Film Review: Dawn of the Planet of the Apes

If Rise of the Planet of the Apes successfully restarted the dormant Apes franchise, the superior Dawn indicates the grand saga this new iteration might become. More »

Tammy
Film Review: Tammy

Hollywood’s most bankable big-screen comedienne is on the buddy-comedy road again, with a most worthy companion—a brilliantly out-there Susan Sarandon. More »

Player for the Film Journal International website.


ADVERTISEMENT



INDUSTRY GUIDES

» Blue Sheets
FJI's guide to upcoming movie releases, including films in production and development. Check back weekly for the latest additions.

» Distribution Guide
» Equipment Guide
» Exhibition Guide

ORDER A PRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Film Journal International

Subscribe to the monthly print edition of Film Journal International and get the full visual impact of this valuable resource for the cinema business.

» Click Here

SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES

Learn how to promote your company at the Film Expo Group events: ShowEast, CineEurope, and CineAsia.

» Click Here