Reviews


Film Review: Personal Tailor

Sharp satire details a half-dozen cases from a Chinese firm that tries to fulfill its clients' fantasies.

-By Daniel Eagan


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1391698-Personal_Tailor_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

Like TV's old "Fantasy Island," Personal Tailor lets a few guest stars play out their dreams in stories with moral overtones. The movie's carefree style and ingratiating cast help disguise a cynical outlook, making this one of the more intriguing releases from China this year.

Director Feng Xiaogang's recent movies include big, lumbering historical epics Back to 1942 and Aftershock, but he made his reputation with sunny, crowd-pleasing comedies like If You Are the One. Personal Tailor mimics the latter's easygoing charm while tackling some pretty intractable modern-day problems.

The title refers to a company run by Yang (the extravagantly talented Ge You) that pulls together elaborate settings and characters to persuade its clients that they are living their dreams. In the opening black-and-white segment, Ge plays a debonair but evil Nazi colonel so his client can enact a Resistance agent's martyrdom.

It's not a very promising start, but Shuo Wang's episodic screenplay throws out so many good ideas that they overtake the weak ones. In "Honest Instincts," a chauffeur played by Fan Wei wants to be a good politician, unlike the corrupt ones he's driven around. As the "Chief," he asks Yang's staff to tempt him with illegal offers, leading to some bright, inventive scams. It takes a massage from a "Secretary Lu" (a winsome Li Xiaolu) for the Chief to lose his scruples.

In the longest segment, "Bloody Vulgar," a blockbuster film director (Li Chengru) wants to give up schlock for "high art," despite Yang's belief that "Chinese movies, however bad, are never art." Operating on the theory that if they like something, it's not good enough to be art, Yang and his staff immerse Li in hilariously pretentious performance pieces.

Staffers Bai (Bai Baihe, who is in the weepy romantic hit The Stolen Years) and Ma Qing (Zheng Kai) help out in "Mo' Money," a sweet-natured fable about a poor woman (Song Dandan) who gets to pretend that she's wealthy for a day. Being rich is harder than it looks, as Yang has to instruct Song about how to treat servants dismissively, how to spend too much money on real estate, and how to cheat employees. "Behind every billionaire lies a mountain of debt," he explains.

Ge plays several roles in Personal Tailor: peasant, tycoon, even a Thai prince. In each he is unfailingly smart, funny and appealing. Bai and Li make a formidable pair, alternately seductive and brittle.

Personal Tailor looks as good as just about any recent Hollywood comedy, and feels about a half-year newer. Characters make fun of blogs, complain about McMansions, film themselves on smartphones, and take sex in all its iterations for granted.

If Personal Tailor seems slapdash, even sloppy at times, it may be because the movie ran into censorship problems. Presenting politicians as universal cheats and the wealthy as above the law was not enough for Feng. He ends Personal Tailor with disturbing examples of China's pollution troubles. As Bai notes, "This is our fault, we created this mess." It's an odd but effective ending to a consistently surprising comedy.


Film Review: Personal Tailor

Sharp satire details a half-dozen cases from a Chinese firm that tries to fulfill its clients' fantasies.

Dec 19, 2013

-By Daniel Eagan


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1391698-Personal_Tailor_Md.jpg

Like TV's old "Fantasy Island," Personal Tailor lets a few guest stars play out their dreams in stories with moral overtones. The movie's carefree style and ingratiating cast help disguise a cynical outlook, making this one of the more intriguing releases from China this year.

Director Feng Xiaogang's recent movies include big, lumbering historical epics Back to 1942 and Aftershock, but he made his reputation with sunny, crowd-pleasing comedies like If You Are the One. Personal Tailor mimics the latter's easygoing charm while tackling some pretty intractable modern-day problems.

The title refers to a company run by Yang (the extravagantly talented Ge You) that pulls together elaborate settings and characters to persuade its clients that they are living their dreams. In the opening black-and-white segment, Ge plays a debonair but evil Nazi colonel so his client can enact a Resistance agent's martyrdom.

It's not a very promising start, but Shuo Wang's episodic screenplay throws out so many good ideas that they overtake the weak ones. In "Honest Instincts," a chauffeur played by Fan Wei wants to be a good politician, unlike the corrupt ones he's driven around. As the "Chief," he asks Yang's staff to tempt him with illegal offers, leading to some bright, inventive scams. It takes a massage from a "Secretary Lu" (a winsome Li Xiaolu) for the Chief to lose his scruples.

In the longest segment, "Bloody Vulgar," a blockbuster film director (Li Chengru) wants to give up schlock for "high art," despite Yang's belief that "Chinese movies, however bad, are never art." Operating on the theory that if they like something, it's not good enough to be art, Yang and his staff immerse Li in hilariously pretentious performance pieces.

Staffers Bai (Bai Baihe, who is in the weepy romantic hit The Stolen Years) and Ma Qing (Zheng Kai) help out in "Mo' Money," a sweet-natured fable about a poor woman (Song Dandan) who gets to pretend that she's wealthy for a day. Being rich is harder than it looks, as Yang has to instruct Song about how to treat servants dismissively, how to spend too much money on real estate, and how to cheat employees. "Behind every billionaire lies a mountain of debt," he explains.

Ge plays several roles in Personal Tailor: peasant, tycoon, even a Thai prince. In each he is unfailingly smart, funny and appealing. Bai and Li make a formidable pair, alternately seductive and brittle.

Personal Tailor looks as good as just about any recent Hollywood comedy, and feels about a half-year newer. Characters make fun of blogs, complain about McMansions, film themselves on smartphones, and take sex in all its iterations for granted.

If Personal Tailor seems slapdash, even sloppy at times, it may be because the movie ran into censorship problems. Presenting politicians as universal cheats and the wealthy as above the law was not enough for Feng. He ends Personal Tailor with disturbing examples of China's pollution troubles. As Bai notes, "This is our fault, we created this mess." It's an odd but effective ending to a consistently surprising comedy.

ADVERTISEMENT



REVIEWS

Penguins of Madagascar
Film Review: Penguins of Madagascar

Frenetic vehicle for supporting players from the Madagascar films will entertain kids but prove a little wearying for their parents. More »

imitation game
Film Review: The Imitation Game

Terrific biopic about world-class mathematician and social misfit Alan Turing, who, in spite of a painful struggle with his homosexuality, helped the Allies break the code of the Nazis' Enigma machine. More »

Player for the Film Journal International website.


ADVERTISEMENT



INDUSTRY GUIDES

» Blue Sheets
FJI's guide to upcoming movie releases, including films in production and development. Check back weekly for the latest additions.

» Distribution Guide
» Equipment Guide
» Exhibition Guide

ORDER A PRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Film Journal International

Subscribe to the monthly print edition of Film Journal International and get the full visual impact of this valuable resource for the cinema business.

» Click Here

SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES

Learn how to promote your company at the Film Expo Group events: ShowEast, CineEurope, and CineAsia.

» Click Here