-By Sarah Sluis
For movie details, please click here.
Shows like “America’s Next Top Model” pride themselves on plucking
girls from obscure corners of Middle America and into catwalk fame.
But Waris Dirie’s story tops them all. Born into a nomadic life in
Somalia, Waris (Liya Kebede) was discovered by a renowned
photographer in London in the late 1980s and launched into a career
as a supermodel. She later turned her celebrity into a platform to
speak out against female genital mutilation (FGM), a practice that
almost killed her and led to lasting problems.
Desert Flower, an adaptation of her book, preserves the
inspirational and singular tenor of her story, but fumbles its
execution. Certain lines feel obvious, too expository, or blatantly
foreshadow events. “Don’t ever leave me,” Waris’ brother pleads in
that familiar way that signals just the opposite. Mere scenes
later, she takes off for good. Waris ends up in London, working as
a maid for relatives in the Somalia embassy. When war breaks out in
Somalia, she stays, on her own.
Surprisingly, the movie focuses little on culture shock.
Post-modeling career, we see Waris navigating a sleek modern
apartment and using its microwave with ease, but in the early
scenes in London, she seems to withdraw from situations that puzzle
her or depend on her comprehension of the English language.
Throughout the movie, her feelings remain closed off from viewers.
Her personality cannot be described beyond rough indicators like
“determined” and “modest.” The film feels just like the celebrity
memoir it is: matter-of-fact descriptions of events that avoid
deeper probing of the person’s psyche.
After befriending a shopgirl/would-be ballerina (Sally Hawkins),
Waris does receive a tutoring in Western sexuality, but a
heartbreaking one. She realizes English people don’t have to
undergo female genital mutilation, while the pain from her
condition eventually leads her to the hospital. In the movie’s most
powerful scene, a Somali hospital aide translates the doctor’s
request for her to schedule an operation into a stinging indictment
of her character, unbeknownst to those around them. “Why are you
letting a white man look at you?” He asks. “Our customs are not
their concern.”
The final portion of the movie focuses on Waris’ campaign to raise
awareness about FGM, which includes a speech at the United Nations.
Unfortunately, since most of the movie builds to the launch of her
modeling career, this part feels tacked on and incongruous with the
rest of the story. If writer-director Sherry Hormann had better
integrated these two subjects, perhaps the movie wouldn’t feel so
overlong. Hormann also imposes a melodramatic, TV-movie style that
can only hurt the movie’s theatrical prospects, though it’s leaps
and bounds above the typical Lifetime Original Movie.
Desert Flower has already earned $9 million in Germany,
where Waris’ book was a long-running bestseller. Box-office
prospects here will be more limited. Though straightforward in its
telling, Waris’ story is still quite affecting, and the subject
matter fresh and eye-opening.
Film Review: Desert Flower
This inspiring story of a nomad-turned-model is executed in the style of a made-for-TV movie.
March 17, 2011
-By Sarah Sluis
Shows like “America’s Next Top Model” pride themselves on plucking girls from obscure corners of Middle America and into catwalk fame. But Waris Dirie’s story tops them all. Born into a nomadic life in Somalia, Waris (Liya Kebede) was discovered by a renowned photographer in London in the late 1980s and launched into a career as a supermodel. She later turned her celebrity into a platform to speak out against female genital mutilation (FGM), a practice that almost killed her and led to lasting problems.
Desert Flower, an adaptation of her book, preserves the inspirational and singular tenor of her story, but fumbles its execution. Certain lines feel obvious, too expository, or blatantly foreshadow events. “Don’t ever leave me,” Waris’ brother pleads in that familiar way that signals just the opposite. Mere scenes later, she takes off for good. Waris ends up in London, working as a maid for relatives in the Somalia embassy. When war breaks out in Somalia, she stays, on her own.
Surprisingly, the movie focuses little on culture shock. Post-modeling career, we see Waris navigating a sleek modern apartment and using its microwave with ease, but in the early scenes in London, she seems to withdraw from situations that puzzle her or depend on her comprehension of the English language. Throughout the movie, her feelings remain closed off from viewers. Her personality cannot be described beyond rough indicators like “determined” and “modest.” The film feels just like the celebrity memoir it is: matter-of-fact descriptions of events that avoid deeper probing of the person’s psyche.
After befriending a shopgirl/would-be ballerina (Sally Hawkins), Waris does receive a tutoring in Western sexuality, but a heartbreaking one. She realizes English people don’t have to undergo female genital mutilation, while the pain from her condition eventually leads her to the hospital. In the movie’s most powerful scene, a Somali hospital aide translates the doctor’s request for her to schedule an operation into a stinging indictment of her character, unbeknownst to those around them. “Why are you letting a white man look at you?” He asks. “Our customs are not their concern.”
The final portion of the movie focuses on Waris’ campaign to raise awareness about FGM, which includes a speech at the United Nations. Unfortunately, since most of the movie builds to the launch of her modeling career, this part feels tacked on and incongruous with the rest of the story. If writer-director Sherry Hormann had better integrated these two subjects, perhaps the movie wouldn’t feel so overlong. Hormann also imposes a melodramatic, TV-movie style that can only hurt the movie’s theatrical prospects, though it’s leaps and bounds above the typical Lifetime Original Movie.
Desert Flower has already earned $9 million in Germany, where Waris’ book was a long-running bestseller. Box-office prospects here will be more limited. Though straightforward in its telling, Waris’ story is still quite affecting, and the subject matter fresh and eye-opening.