-By Eric Monder
For movie details, please click here.
Cool and spare,
Eccentricities of a Blonde-haired Girl marks
the 48th—but
not the latest—feature from 101-year-old
director Manoel de Oliveira, who, by the way, has an even newer
film currently making the festival circuit rounds. Apart from the
inspiring fact that the Portuguese-born director is able to make a
film, any film, at such an advanced age,
Eccentricities is
good enough to attract more than art-house cinephiles. This
mesmerizing little tale is mysterious but straightforward enough to
win over any audience.
De Oliveira’s screenplay, based on a short story by celebrated
fellow countryman Eca de Queirós, concerns a young man, Macario
(Ricardo Trepa, the director’s grandson), who tells a tale of woe
to a sympathetic stranger on a train (Leonor Silveira). Macario
relates the recent events that occurred while he was a bookkeeper
working in a Lisbon shop for his strict uncle (Diogo Dória).
In his story, day after day, Macario becomes drawn to a beautiful
blonde, Luisa (Catarina Wallenstein), he sees at a window across
the alley from his upstairs office. Through a mutual friend,
Macario arranges to have a formal introduction to the young woman.
The meeting, at an elegant salon, goes surprisingly well. But just
as Macario tells his uncle his wish to marry Luisa, his uncle
angrily fires him.
Without a job, and feeling he needs money in order to propose
marriage, Macario takes a position in another city. Upon his
return, he asks Luisa’s mother for her daughter’s hand in marriage.
Luisa accepts the offer but, simultaneously, one of Macario’s
friends involves him in a bad business deal and he loses all his
money again. This time, Macario’s uncle saves the day by giving him
his old job back. Yet an unexpected event throws the upcoming
nuptials into complete jeopardy.
De Oliveira’s individual signature is apparent in
Eccentricities, though the tone and narrative recall parts
of
Claire’s Knee,
That Obscure Object of Desire, and
even a little
Vertigo. Thematically, de Oliveira slyly
criticizes the oppressive nature of capitalism on the human
condition. Balancing dark humor and romanticism, he creates a
lovely but cutting recession-era allegory.
At a brief 64 minutes,
Eccentricities never wastes a moment
of screen time. The still-shot long takes lend a Zola-like
naturalism to a story best described as a fable. Except for a
diegetic harp solo, there is no music in the film and de Oliveira
makes great use of sounds. For example, the distant train noises
during the flashbacks suggest the past and present aren’t so
separate. The lack of close-ups also keeps the emotions in check
(don’t expect any kind of Hollywood melodrama) and the “twist”
ending disappointed me at first but became resonant, even haunting,
the more I thought about it.
My only real dissatisfaction was with the “eccentric girl” herself.
Unless de Oliveira wanted the viewer to witness an obsession
completely from the objective outside, he should have cast someone
more mysterious and attractive than newcomer Catarina Wallenstein.
The actress performs acceptably enough in a role that is sometimes
literal window dressing, but it is hard to understand Macario’s
excitement over this pretty but vapid person the way Wallenstein
portrays her. Imagine Nabokov’s Lolita the way she is seen at the
end of the novel as the Lolita we are introduced to at the
beginning and you will know what I mean. The film requires an
actress on the order of either Carole Bouquet or Angela Molina in
That Obscure Object of Desire. Perhaps as intended irony, de
Oliveira ensemble regular Leonor Silveira, as the patient train
passenger, exudes more depth than Wallenstein or the “girl” of the
story. The very final shot suggests this was deliberate on de
Oliveira’s part—as is everything else about this interesting film.
Film Review: Eccentricities of a Blonde-haired Girl
Eccentricities of a Blonde-haired Girl is almost as seductive as its title suggests.
Aug 5, 2010
-By Eric Monder
Cool and spare,
Eccentricities of a Blonde-haired Girl marks the 48th—but
not the latest—feature from 101-year-old director Manoel de Oliveira, who, by the way, has an even newer film currently making the festival circuit rounds. Apart from the inspiring fact that the Portuguese-born director is able to make a film, any film, at such an advanced age,
Eccentricities is good enough to attract more than art-house cinephiles. This mesmerizing little tale is mysterious but straightforward enough to win over any audience.
De Oliveira’s screenplay, based on a short story by celebrated fellow countryman Eca de Queirós, concerns a young man, Macario (Ricardo Trepa, the director’s grandson), who tells a tale of woe to a sympathetic stranger on a train (Leonor Silveira). Macario relates the recent events that occurred while he was a bookkeeper working in a Lisbon shop for his strict uncle (Diogo Dória).
In his story, day after day, Macario becomes drawn to a beautiful blonde, Luisa (Catarina Wallenstein), he sees at a window across the alley from his upstairs office. Through a mutual friend, Macario arranges to have a formal introduction to the young woman. The meeting, at an elegant salon, goes surprisingly well. But just as Macario tells his uncle his wish to marry Luisa, his uncle angrily fires him.
Without a job, and feeling he needs money in order to propose marriage, Macario takes a position in another city. Upon his return, he asks Luisa’s mother for her daughter’s hand in marriage. Luisa accepts the offer but, simultaneously, one of Macario’s friends involves him in a bad business deal and he loses all his money again. This time, Macario’s uncle saves the day by giving him his old job back. Yet an unexpected event throws the upcoming nuptials into complete jeopardy.
De Oliveira’s individual signature is apparent in
Eccentricities, though the tone and narrative recall parts of
Claire’s Knee,
That Obscure Object of Desire, and even a little
Vertigo. Thematically, de Oliveira slyly criticizes the oppressive nature of capitalism on the human condition. Balancing dark humor and romanticism, he creates a lovely but cutting recession-era allegory.
At a brief 64 minutes,
Eccentricities never wastes a moment of screen time. The still-shot long takes lend a Zola-like naturalism to a story best described as a fable. Except for a diegetic harp solo, there is no music in the film and de Oliveira makes great use of sounds. For example, the distant train noises during the flashbacks suggest the past and present aren’t so separate. The lack of close-ups also keeps the emotions in check (don’t expect any kind of Hollywood melodrama) and the “twist” ending disappointed me at first but became resonant, even haunting, the more I thought about it.
My only real dissatisfaction was with the “eccentric girl” herself. Unless de Oliveira wanted the viewer to witness an obsession completely from the objective outside, he should have cast someone more mysterious and attractive than newcomer Catarina Wallenstein. The actress performs acceptably enough in a role that is sometimes literal window dressing, but it is hard to understand Macario’s excitement over this pretty but vapid person the way Wallenstein portrays her. Imagine Nabokov’s Lolita the way she is seen at the end of the novel as the Lolita we are introduced to at the beginning and you will know what I mean. The film requires an actress on the order of either Carole Bouquet or Angela Molina in
That Obscure Object of Desire. Perhaps as intended irony, de Oliveira ensemble regular Leonor Silveira, as the patient train passenger, exudes more depth than Wallenstein or the “girl” of the story. The very final shot suggests this was deliberate on de Oliveira’s part—as is everything else about this interesting film.