Reviews - Major Releases


Film Review: Her

Singularly brilliant concept makes for a highly intriguing viewing experience until it begins to peter out towards the end.

Dec 16, 2013

-By David Noh


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1391038-Her_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

In not-so-distant future Los Angeles, Theodore Twombly (Joaquin Phoenix) is seriously depressed. About to be divorced from his beautiful wife (Rooney Mara), he toils as a Cyrano-esque ghostwriter of love letters to other people for a company specializing in just that service. There's a definite void in his life, but it’s soon filled by Samantha aka OS1 (Scarlett Johansson). She is no regular girl—in fact, she is not a girl at all, but a voice on the latest, supposedly greatest artificial intelligence operating system. At first installed in Theodore's head to organize his life, her warmly nurturing presence soon becomes indispensable to him, and from that romantic feelings grow. She seems to dig him, too, and Theodore is floating on air until the inevitable realization about who—or what—exactly Samantha is finally becomes apparent to him.

Working for the first time from his own original script, director Spike Jonze creates a striking, sleekly designed dystopian world that, however stylized it may be with its scarily clean, even sterile environs (some of the film was shot in China) and its men dressed similarly in weirdly high-waisted slacks, seems frighteningly not all that removed from today. You wonder if he drew inspiration for Her from watching so many people unquestioningly going through their daily lives, jabbering away to "nobody," aka whoever is on the other side of their ubiquitous ear-buds. It's a fiendishly clever concept, his most satisfying outing since the brilliant Being John Malkovich, rife with droll moments and real surprise. But, unfortunately, the movie loses steam mostly due to the concept of Theodore's character, who, as played by the ever-unpredictable Phoenix—who, with Gladiator and The Master has already played all kinds of crazy—is too passive the eternal sufferer to sustain our interest with all of his incessant moroseness, which after a while begins to seem like some dully repeated joke. By this point, you can almost play the same cinematic parlor game with Phoenix as you used to be able to do with Jennifer Jones: Name one movie in which this actor was normal.

An attractive cast ably fleshes things out. Amy Adams is very sympathetic and—blessedly—normal-seeming as Twombly's ever-platonic best friend, although it is probably she he should have ended up with. Mara has a nicely biting scene with Phoenix, and her acrid prettiness and attitude go a long way towards explaining how he got to be the way he is. Olivia Wilde also gets laughs as one-half of an initially lovely date that suddenly goes straight to hell.

But it is Scarlett Johansson who is the film's real coup. Although it’s only a vocal performance, talk has been bandied about for best acting awards for her, and indeed her fetchingly husky tones have never been more suggestive or alluring than they are here. One could easily fall in love with a voice like that, coupled with so much genuine empathy and sage advice. And when things start to go south because of Theodore's incessant need to cross boundaries with who and what she is, the distraught, dripping sadness in her voice is quite heartbreaking.


Film Review: Her

Singularly brilliant concept makes for a highly intriguing viewing experience until it begins to peter out towards the end.

Dec 16, 2013

-By David Noh


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1391038-Her_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

In not-so-distant future Los Angeles, Theodore Twombly (Joaquin Phoenix) is seriously depressed. About to be divorced from his beautiful wife (Rooney Mara), he toils as a Cyrano-esque ghostwriter of love letters to other people for a company specializing in just that service. There's a definite void in his life, but it’s soon filled by Samantha aka OS1 (Scarlett Johansson). She is no regular girl—in fact, she is not a girl at all, but a voice on the latest, supposedly greatest artificial intelligence operating system. At first installed in Theodore's head to organize his life, her warmly nurturing presence soon becomes indispensable to him, and from that romantic feelings grow. She seems to dig him, too, and Theodore is floating on air until the inevitable realization about who—or what—exactly Samantha is finally becomes apparent to him.

Working for the first time from his own original script, director Spike Jonze creates a striking, sleekly designed dystopian world that, however stylized it may be with its scarily clean, even sterile environs (some of the film was shot in China) and its men dressed similarly in weirdly high-waisted slacks, seems frighteningly not all that removed from today. You wonder if he drew inspiration for Her from watching so many people unquestioningly going through their daily lives, jabbering away to "nobody," aka whoever is on the other side of their ubiquitous ear-buds. It's a fiendishly clever concept, his most satisfying outing since the brilliant Being John Malkovich, rife with droll moments and real surprise. But, unfortunately, the movie loses steam mostly due to the concept of Theodore's character, who, as played by the ever-unpredictable Phoenix—who, with Gladiator and The Master has already played all kinds of crazy—is too passive the eternal sufferer to sustain our interest with all of his incessant moroseness, which after a while begins to seem like some dully repeated joke. By this point, you can almost play the same cinematic parlor game with Phoenix as you used to be able to do with Jennifer Jones: Name one movie in which this actor was normal.

An attractive cast ably fleshes things out. Amy Adams is very sympathetic and—blessedly—normal-seeming as Twombly's ever-platonic best friend, although it is probably she he should have ended up with. Mara has a nicely biting scene with Phoenix, and her acrid prettiness and attitude go a long way towards explaining how he got to be the way he is. Olivia Wilde also gets laughs as one-half of an initially lovely date that suddenly goes straight to hell.

But it is Scarlett Johansson who is the film's real coup. Although it’s only a vocal performance, talk has been bandied about for best acting awards for her, and indeed her fetchingly husky tones have never been more suggestive or alluring than they are here. One could easily fall in love with a voice like that, coupled with so much genuine empathy and sage advice. And when things start to go south because of Theodore's incessant need to cross boundaries with who and what she is, the distraught, dripping sadness in her voice is quite heartbreaking.
Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Author: 
Rate This Article: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
 

More Major Releases

Project Almanac
Film Review: Project Almanac

Saying this underbaked Chronicle knockoff is meant for teenagers is an insult to the intelligence of teenagers everywhere. More »

The Loft
Film Review: The Loft

Low rent. More »

Film Review: Black or White

Kevin Costner continues a quietly incremental comeback with this child-custody drama. It could have been his Kramer vs. Kramer–but doesn’t even come close. More »

Wild Card
Film Review: Wild Card

Security expert fights a Las Vegas thug in a pointless remake of the 1986 Burt Reynolds vehicle Heat. More »

ADVERTISEMENT



REVIEWS

Project Almanac
Film Review: Project Almanac

Saying this underbaked Chronicle knockoff is meant for teenagers is an insult to the intelligence of teenagers everywhere. More »

The Wedding Ringer
Film Review: The Wedding Ringer

Intermittently amusing bro-comedy trifle that confirms Kevin Hart's talent, though not his taste in material. More »

Player for the Film Journal International website.


ADVERTISEMENT



INDUSTRY GUIDES

» Blue Sheets
FJI's guide to upcoming movie releases, including films in production and development. Check back weekly for the latest additions.

» Distribution Guide
» Equipment Guide
» Exhibition Guide

ORDER A PRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Film Journal International

Subscribe to the monthly print edition of Film Journal International and get the full visual impact of this valuable resource for the cinema business.

» Click Here

SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES

Learn how to promote your company at the Film Expo Group events: ShowEast, CineEurope, and CineAsia.

» Click Here