Reviews - Major Releases


Film Review: Promised Land

Intelligent, sincere diatribe against venal corporate interests is highly watchable, only marred by an unconvincingly slick denouement.

Dec 26, 2012

-By David Noh


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1369638-Promised_Land_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

“Fracking,” the controversial drilling technique for natural gas, is at the heart of Gus Van Sant’s Promised Land. To the small, economically hard-hit rural town of McKinley come Steve Butler (Matt Damon) and Sue Thomason (Frances McDormand), sales partners representing Global, a billion-dollar fracking corporation, with the mission of persuading the local residents to sell their land. They receive a variety of responses, from eager beavers all too willing to sign over for fast—but actually measly—bucks to staunch resistance from the more ecologically minded, headed by schoolteacher Frank Yates (Hal Holbrook). In addition, they have to contend with the arrival of Dustin Noble (John Krasinski), an environmental activist who definitely puts a crimp in their plans as he brings up pesky issues like the decimation of a proud agricultural tradition and the air and water pollution brought on by fracking.

Promised Land is diametrically opposed to the more challengingly “arty” Van Sant efforts like Elephant, Gerry and Last Days, with their oblique nature and logy pacing. He admirably has put himself firmly in the service of bringing this story—important in its rare feature-film address of our present-day economy—to the screen with a minimum of auteurial frills. The script, by Damon and Krasinski, has something of the cozily muckraking quality of old Frank Capra films in which smalltown mentalities uneasily rub against city-slicker agendas, and is well-acted and absorbing enough. You do come to care about this beat-down country town and its residents, but the final denouement, involving a huge plot twist and a “MacGuffin” lifted from Blow-up, feels contrived, rather negating viewer involvement. You become a bit too aware of the fact that this screenplay was indeed written by actors, and what ensues bespeaks more juicy, histrionic switcheroo opportunities than human verisimilitude, with a big ole grandstanding, change-of-faith, 11 o’clock speech for Damon.
And Van Sant’s direction may indeed be a bit too square. Although his trademark use of fast-flying clouds is present, more messy artistry here could have been used to conceal the baldness of the scripted inauthenticity.

Damon gives a brave, no-nonsense performance as a weasily unquestioning company dog, without ever once sneaking an adorable peek at the audience to be liked. His status as a true, identifiable movie star is happily proved here by the fact that you do still care about him, even with Butler’s venal, self-absorbed shallowness. Krasinski is also very good—although the character he is playing is little more than a pure contrivance—with an ingratiating, easy hipster’s charm. McDormand is reliably feisty and drily humorous, but this is a part she could have played in her sleep, and all too subsidiary. Holbrook is forceful, but I’m afraid brings something of a patented showbiz kind of intensity to his role that stands out like a sore thumb among all the strenuously natural McKinley residents. Rosemarie DeWitt adds some sweet strength as a schoolteacher love interest for the two male leads.


Film Review: Promised Land

Intelligent, sincere diatribe against venal corporate interests is highly watchable, only marred by an unconvincingly slick denouement.

Dec 26, 2012

-By David Noh


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1369638-Promised_Land_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

“Fracking,” the controversial drilling technique for natural gas, is at the heart of Gus Van Sant’s Promised Land. To the small, economically hard-hit rural town of McKinley come Steve Butler (Matt Damon) and Sue Thomason (Frances McDormand), sales partners representing Global, a billion-dollar fracking corporation, with the mission of persuading the local residents to sell their land. They receive a variety of responses, from eager beavers all too willing to sign over for fast—but actually measly—bucks to staunch resistance from the more ecologically minded, headed by schoolteacher Frank Yates (Hal Holbrook). In addition, they have to contend with the arrival of Dustin Noble (John Krasinski), an environmental activist who definitely puts a crimp in their plans as he brings up pesky issues like the decimation of a proud agricultural tradition and the air and water pollution brought on by fracking.

Promised Land is diametrically opposed to the more challengingly “arty” Van Sant efforts like Elephant, Gerry and Last Days, with their oblique nature and logy pacing. He admirably has put himself firmly in the service of bringing this story—important in its rare feature-film address of our present-day economy—to the screen with a minimum of auteurial frills. The script, by Damon and Krasinski, has something of the cozily muckraking quality of old Frank Capra films in which smalltown mentalities uneasily rub against city-slicker agendas, and is well-acted and absorbing enough. You do come to care about this beat-down country town and its residents, but the final denouement, involving a huge plot twist and a “MacGuffin” lifted from Blow-up, feels contrived, rather negating viewer involvement. You become a bit too aware of the fact that this screenplay was indeed written by actors, and what ensues bespeaks more juicy, histrionic switcheroo opportunities than human verisimilitude, with a big ole grandstanding, change-of-faith, 11 o’clock speech for Damon.
And Van Sant’s direction may indeed be a bit too square. Although his trademark use of fast-flying clouds is present, more messy artistry here could have been used to conceal the baldness of the scripted inauthenticity.

Damon gives a brave, no-nonsense performance as a weasily unquestioning company dog, without ever once sneaking an adorable peek at the audience to be liked. His status as a true, identifiable movie star is happily proved here by the fact that you do still care about him, even with Butler’s venal, self-absorbed shallowness. Krasinski is also very good—although the character he is playing is little more than a pure contrivance—with an ingratiating, easy hipster’s charm. McDormand is reliably feisty and drily humorous, but this is a part she could have played in her sleep, and all too subsidiary. Holbrook is forceful, but I’m afraid brings something of a patented showbiz kind of intensity to his role that stands out like a sore thumb among all the strenuously natural McKinley residents. Rosemarie DeWitt adds some sweet strength as a schoolteacher love interest for the two male leads.
Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Author: 
Rate This Article: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
 

More Major Releases

Dawn of the Apes review
Film Review: Dawn of the Planet of the Apes

If Rise of the Planet of the Apes successfully restarted the dormant Apes franchise, the superior Dawn indicates the grand saga this new iteration might become. More »

Deliver Us From Evil
Film Review: Deliver Us From Evil

An effective if imperfect meeting of the detective film and the exorcism-based fright flick. More »

Earth to Echo
Film Review: Earth to Echo

Earth to Echo is a shame-free replication of (or homage to) E.T. and Chronicle, but mainly hits home with its universal worry: What happens when best teen buds are forced to separate? More »

Tammy
Film Review: Tammy

Hollywood’s most bankable big-screen comedienne is on the buddy-comedy road again, with a most worthy companion—a brilliantly out-there Susan Sarandon. More »

ADVERTISEMENT



REVIEWS

Dawn of the Apes review
Film Review: Dawn of the Planet of the Apes

If Rise of the Planet of the Apes successfully restarted the dormant Apes franchise, the superior Dawn indicates the grand saga this new iteration might become. More »

Tammy
Film Review: Tammy

Hollywood’s most bankable big-screen comedienne is on the buddy-comedy road again, with a most worthy companion—a brilliantly out-there Susan Sarandon. More »

Player for the Film Journal International website.


ADVERTISEMENT



INDUSTRY GUIDES

» Blue Sheets
FJI's guide to upcoming movie releases, including films in production and development. Check back weekly for the latest additions.

» Distribution Guide
» Equipment Guide
» Exhibition Guide

ORDER A PRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Film Journal International

Subscribe to the monthly print edition of Film Journal International and get the full visual impact of this valuable resource for the cinema business.

» Click Here

SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES

Learn how to promote your company at the Film Expo Group events: ShowEast, CineEurope, and CineAsia.

» Click Here