Reviews - Specialty Releases


Film Review: Empty Nest

Tasteful and intelligent to a fault, but critically lacking in truly absorbing excitement.

April 24, 2009

-By David Noh


filmjournal/photos/stylus/80414-Empty_Nest_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

Leonardo (Oscar Martinez) is an eminent Argentinean writer who, with his wife Martha (Cecilia Roth), faces a dilemma common to many middle-aged couples—when the kids grow up and leave home and you are forced to finally confront your life partner again, strictly a deux, after decades of familial interruption. The differences between the two become ever more marked, as Leonardo is a solitary sort, content to immerse himself in his work and live largely in his head, while Martha needs social outlets which she finds in throwing parties that he finds disruptive and taking continuing-education courses at night where she meets new people, annoying to him.

Writer-director Daniel Burman has tackled an interesting, highly relevant subject with sensitivity and intelligence in Empty Nest. The problem is that not enough happens here to generate much viewer excitement. Burman captures the weary domestic life of a writer, as we see Leonardo putting up with kids and the chi-chi cocktail party chatter of Martha’s artist and wannabe-artistic friends, as well as irritating couples group therapy in traditionally psych-crazed Buenos Aires, all providing some mild initial amusement. Then we see him striking out on his own, embarking on a semi-tepid affair with a comely young dentist and indulging in his hobby of flying model airplanes (not much thrill to be had there, admittedly). There is one telling moment when an old friend of Leonardo advises him about the necessity to keep the interest going in his marriage: “It’s like things you put away in storage and forget about.”

The performances are marked by humor and considerable braininess, with Martinez a magisterially handsome if somewhat infuriatingly uncommunicative presence, and Roth (an Almodóvar favorite) convincingly showing her frustration at his failings in a way which will seem very familiar to many audience members.

Burman interjects some surreal moments, like a Felliniesque parade of models in a mall stalking Leonardo’s every move, but these seem rather desperate attempts to inject some thrills into the intellectual proceedings without ever being truly organic to the concept. And when the couple goes to Israel to visit their daughter who has married a Jew—both come across as pretty vapid—not enough is made of the basic culture clash and sense of displacement to generate true empathy.


Film Review: Empty Nest

Tasteful and intelligent to a fault, but critically lacking in truly absorbing excitement.

April 24, 2009

-By David Noh


filmjournal/photos/stylus/80414-Empty_Nest_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

Leonardo (Oscar Martinez) is an eminent Argentinean writer who, with his wife Martha (Cecilia Roth), faces a dilemma common to many middle-aged couples—when the kids grow up and leave home and you are forced to finally confront your life partner again, strictly a deux, after decades of familial interruption. The differences between the two become ever more marked, as Leonardo is a solitary sort, content to immerse himself in his work and live largely in his head, while Martha needs social outlets which she finds in throwing parties that he finds disruptive and taking continuing-education courses at night where she meets new people, annoying to him.

Writer-director Daniel Burman has tackled an interesting, highly relevant subject with sensitivity and intelligence in Empty Nest. The problem is that not enough happens here to generate much viewer excitement. Burman captures the weary domestic life of a writer, as we see Leonardo putting up with kids and the chi-chi cocktail party chatter of Martha’s artist and wannabe-artistic friends, as well as irritating couples group therapy in traditionally psych-crazed Buenos Aires, all providing some mild initial amusement. Then we see him striking out on his own, embarking on a semi-tepid affair with a comely young dentist and indulging in his hobby of flying model airplanes (not much thrill to be had there, admittedly). There is one telling moment when an old friend of Leonardo advises him about the necessity to keep the interest going in his marriage: “It’s like things you put away in storage and forget about.”

The performances are marked by humor and considerable braininess, with Martinez a magisterially handsome if somewhat infuriatingly uncommunicative presence, and Roth (an Almodóvar favorite) convincingly showing her frustration at his failings in a way which will seem very familiar to many audience members.

Burman interjects some surreal moments, like a Felliniesque parade of models in a mall stalking Leonardo’s every move, but these seem rather desperate attempts to inject some thrills into the intellectual proceedings without ever being truly organic to the concept. And when the couple goes to Israel to visit their daughter who has married a Jew—both come across as pretty vapid—not enough is made of the basic culture clash and sense of displacement to generate true empathy.
Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Auther: 
Rate This Article: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
 

More Specialty Releases

The Secret in Their Eyes
Film Review: The Secret in Their Eyes

This psychological thriller from Argentine Juan José Campanella boasts a fine cast and spiky dialogue, but thematic bloat blunts its power. More »

Vincere
Film Review: Vincere

Marco Bellocchio's biopic of Mussolini's secret lover offers a different but questionable take on history. More »

Mid-August Lunch
Film Review: Mid-August Lunch

Charming and gently hilarious film features an extraordinary cast of elderly characters. More »

The Exploding Girl
Film Review: The Exploding Girl

Small-scale, effective character study of a young woman struggling to cope with physical and romantic turmoil. More »

ADVERTISEMENT



REVIEWS

Green Zone
Film Review: Green Zone

Paul Greengrass and Matt Damon translate their shock-and-awe Bourne stylistics to a stiff, uneven Iraq War actioner that's more anti-invasion wish fulfillment than ideas-driven drama. More »

Alice in Wonderland
Film Review: Alice in Wonderland

Tim Burton's muddled take on the classic Lewis Carroll tale has moments of lucidity but mostly seems as confused as its titular heroine. More »

Player for the Film Journal International website.


ADVERTISEMENT



INDUSTRY GUIDES

» Blue Sheets
FJI's guide to upcoming movie releases, including films in production and development. Check back weekly for the latest additions.

» Distribution Guide
» Equipment Guide
» Exhibition Guide

ORDER A PRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Film Journal International

Subscribe to the monthly print edition of Film Journal International and get the full visual impact of this valuable resource for the cinema business.

» Click Here

SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES

Learn how to promote your company at the Nielsen Film Group events: ShoWest, Cinema Expo International, ShowEast and CineAsia.

» Click Here