Reviews - Specialty Releases


Film Review: In No Great Hurry: 13 Lessons in Life with Saul Leiter

Documentary portrait of a great photographer is hampered by the taciturn nature of its subject.

Jan 3, 2014

-By David Noh


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1392138-In_No_Great_Hurry_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

The New York street photographs of Saul Leiter, haunting, poignant and yet vibrant with color, made the artist's reputation, and are the centerpiece of this gentle documentary profile. Leiter died last fall at 89, shortly before the film's first showing, and Tomas Leach's doc is elegiac and beautifully photographed, if rather frustratingly thin.

The reasons for this thinness lie in the subject himself. Leiter comes across as a studiously modest, often cantankerous personality with a "Why me?" attitude towards his own personal acclaim, a senior form of urban cool which, given the vagaries and vicissitudes of the New York art world in which he has existed for most of his long life, seems a tad suspect. He is an extremely reticent interviewee, often frustratingly leaving stated thoughts dangling in mid-air with no resolution. We learn little of his personal life in In No Great Hurry, apart from a mention of his family's Holocaust roots and his Orthodox rabbi father's disappointment with his choice of a career. He initially worked in fashion, but there is no evidence of any of that here. He had a longtime companion, Soames Bantry, whom he recalls fondly as he sifts through her belongings in his dusty East Village apartment, cluttered with the found art treasures and detritus of a lifetime. "I killed her—I have to take responsibility for that," he mutters, but such is Leach's cowed reticence that he doesn't pursue that avenue any further.

Leiter's observation that, for him, supportive and loving relationships always took precedence in his life over career success does seem genuinely heartfelt, and a rare moment of personal revelation. Leiter has a loyal, doubtlessly long-suffering assistant, Margit Erb, one of the film's producers, and it would have been salutary to hear a lot more from her as well.

Leach's hesitation is perhaps understandable, as Leiter, although he scrupulously hones his own unassumingly modest image (perhaps the result of only being truly appreciated some 50 years after his greatest artistic activity), is a cranky old bird who does not suffer fools gladly. "He came to Europe to torture me," he observes of Leach, and like so many gifted but difficult doc subjects before him, threatens to not give final approval to the project if he doesn't like the results. "My photos are meant to tickle your left ear" is perhaps his most revealing statement regarding the meaning of his work which Leach so avidly seeks.

Thankfully, as inexpressive as the photographer is, his images speak infinitely interpretable volumes, and I wish Leach had included more of them instead of training his camera so insistently on the man himself, with a rather bullyingly wistful music score pounding on the soundtrack where silence and ambient sound would be a more appropriate fit with Leiter's solitary life. The splitting up of the film into 13 chapters with headings like "Sharing Art" and the titular "In No Great Hurry" seems an unnecessary attempt to add some thematic depth to the footage.


Film Review: In No Great Hurry: 13 Lessons in Life with Saul Leiter

Documentary portrait of a great photographer is hampered by the taciturn nature of its subject.

Jan 3, 2014

-By David Noh


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1392138-In_No_Great_Hurry_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

The New York street photographs of Saul Leiter, haunting, poignant and yet vibrant with color, made the artist's reputation, and are the centerpiece of this gentle documentary profile. Leiter died last fall at 89, shortly before the film's first showing, and Tomas Leach's doc is elegiac and beautifully photographed, if rather frustratingly thin.

The reasons for this thinness lie in the subject himself. Leiter comes across as a studiously modest, often cantankerous personality with a "Why me?" attitude towards his own personal acclaim, a senior form of urban cool which, given the vagaries and vicissitudes of the New York art world in which he has existed for most of his long life, seems a tad suspect. He is an extremely reticent interviewee, often frustratingly leaving stated thoughts dangling in mid-air with no resolution. We learn little of his personal life in In No Great Hurry, apart from a mention of his family's Holocaust roots and his Orthodox rabbi father's disappointment with his choice of a career. He initially worked in fashion, but there is no evidence of any of that here. He had a longtime companion, Soames Bantry, whom he recalls fondly as he sifts through her belongings in his dusty East Village apartment, cluttered with the found art treasures and detritus of a lifetime. "I killed her—I have to take responsibility for that," he mutters, but such is Leach's cowed reticence that he doesn't pursue that avenue any further.

Leiter's observation that, for him, supportive and loving relationships always took precedence in his life over career success does seem genuinely heartfelt, and a rare moment of personal revelation. Leiter has a loyal, doubtlessly long-suffering assistant, Margit Erb, one of the film's producers, and it would have been salutary to hear a lot more from her as well.

Leach's hesitation is perhaps understandable, as Leiter, although he scrupulously hones his own unassumingly modest image (perhaps the result of only being truly appreciated some 50 years after his greatest artistic activity), is a cranky old bird who does not suffer fools gladly. "He came to Europe to torture me," he observes of Leach, and like so many gifted but difficult doc subjects before him, threatens to not give final approval to the project if he doesn't like the results. "My photos are meant to tickle your left ear" is perhaps his most revealing statement regarding the meaning of his work which Leach so avidly seeks.

Thankfully, as inexpressive as the photographer is, his images speak infinitely interpretable volumes, and I wish Leach had included more of them instead of training his camera so insistently on the man himself, with a rather bullyingly wistful music score pounding on the soundtrack where silence and ambient sound would be a more appropriate fit with Leiter's solitary life. The splitting up of the film into 13 chapters with headings like "Sharing Art" and the titular "In No Great Hurry" seems an unnecessary attempt to add some thematic depth to the footage.
Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Author: 
Rate This Article: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
 

More Specialty Releases

BBoy for Life
Film Review: BBoy for Life

The dancing is familiar but the stakes are higher in this moving documentary set in a country with one of the highest murder rates in the world. More »

Manakamana
Film Review: Manakamana

An observational documentary in which the camera captures the passengers of a cable-car cabin in Nepal. More »

Visions of Mary Frank
Film Review: Visions of Mary Frank

Deeply loving, if too slight, documentary about one of the great beauties of the New York art world, who always forged her own path. More »

The Jewish Cardinal
Film Review: The Jewish Cardinal

Informative, absorbing, but as obvious as its title and a bit too glib for its own good, this French import will appeal mainly to religious addicts fascinated by the feverishly agenda-ridden internal workings of the Catholic Church. More »

ADVERTISEMENT



REVIEWS

Draft Day
Film Review: Draft Day

Pro football manager faces crises on the most important day of his career in a well-tooled vehicle for Kevin Costner. More »

Rio 2
Film Review: Rio 2

Busy sequel to the popular animated feature follows the original's blue macaws on a journey from Rio de Janeiro to an endangered rainforest. More »

Player for the Film Journal International website.


ADVERTISEMENT



INDUSTRY GUIDES

» Blue Sheets
FJI's guide to upcoming movie releases, including films in production and development. Check back weekly for the latest additions.

» Distribution Guide
» Equipment Guide
» Exhibition Guide

ORDER A PRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Film Journal International

Subscribe to the monthly print edition of Film Journal International and get the full visual impact of this valuable resource for the cinema business.

» Click Here

SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES

Learn how to promote your company at the Film Expo Group events: ShowEast, CineEurope, and CineAsia.

» Click Here