Reviews - Specialty Releases


Film Review: La Rafle

Drama about the roundup of Jews in Nazi-occupied France suffers from one-dimensional characterizations and whitewashing of French complicity.

Nov 14, 2012

-By Bernard Besserglik


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1367398-La_Rafle_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

Promotion on state-run television and information packages handed out in schools made Rose Bosch's La Rafle, about a particularly murky episode in France's wartime history, a movie event in France. Outside that country, the film's appeal will be more problematic, though its mix of melodrama and spectacle may well draw in popular audiences, perhaps similar to those who saw merit in Roberto Benigni's 1997 concentration-camp comedy, Life Is Beautiful.

Bosch's depiction of the operation by collaborationist authorities that saw 13,000 Jews, including 4,000 children, swept up and parked in transit camps, including an indoor cycling stadium, before being sent to their deaths in Auschwitz is deeply sentimental and depends heavily on pathos for its effect.

The movie's focus begins with the Weismann family, Shmuel and Sura (Gad Elmaleh and Raphaelle Agogue) and their son Jo (Hugo Leverdez), as they are caught up in a police raid on a Jewish quarter in a picture-postcard Montmartre. The film then expands to take in a doctor, David Sheinbaum (Jean Reno), who struggles to minister to the deportees' needs, and a non-Jewish nurse, Annette Monod (Mélanie Laurent from Inglourious Basterds), who accompanies them in their transit-camp ordeal.

Written as well as directed by Bosch (who scripted Ridley Scott's 1492: Conquest of Paradise), the movie is set at a high emotional pitch that fails to disguise the fact that it is overdocumented and underdramatized. La Rafle is history by numbers, ticking off key events as they occur and inserting gobbets of factual information—none new or revelatory—into the narrative.

The characters are two-dimensional and the cast is required to do little more than emote and express high-minded sentiments of one form or another. Historical context is provided by scenes representing Hitler at his Eagle's Nest in Berchtesgaden or the Vichy prime minister Pierre Laval signing off on the deportations.

In its earnestness, the film strikes too many false notes, often undermining scenes intended to carry an intense emotional charge, most notably the separation of the Jewish children from their parents. But perhaps its greatest failing, and the main source of the unease that the film arouses, is its determination to let the French population at large off the hook. With a single exception (a blowsy baker's wife), the people of Paris are shown as doing their noble best to foil or hinder the operation—an entirely dubious proposition—and a closing title adds a self-congratulatory note.

A bankable cast, a hint of controversy and high production values may play in their favor commercially, but Bosch and her producer-husband Ilan Goldman have come dangerously close to making a feel-good movie about the Holocaust.
The Hollywood Reporter


Film Review: La Rafle

Drama about the roundup of Jews in Nazi-occupied France suffers from one-dimensional characterizations and whitewashing of French complicity.

Nov 14, 2012

-By Bernard Besserglik


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1367398-La_Rafle_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

Promotion on state-run television and information packages handed out in schools made Rose Bosch's La Rafle, about a particularly murky episode in France's wartime history, a movie event in France. Outside that country, the film's appeal will be more problematic, though its mix of melodrama and spectacle may well draw in popular audiences, perhaps similar to those who saw merit in Roberto Benigni's 1997 concentration-camp comedy, Life Is Beautiful.

Bosch's depiction of the operation by collaborationist authorities that saw 13,000 Jews, including 4,000 children, swept up and parked in transit camps, including an indoor cycling stadium, before being sent to their deaths in Auschwitz is deeply sentimental and depends heavily on pathos for its effect.

The movie's focus begins with the Weismann family, Shmuel and Sura (Gad Elmaleh and Raphaelle Agogue) and their son Jo (Hugo Leverdez), as they are caught up in a police raid on a Jewish quarter in a picture-postcard Montmartre. The film then expands to take in a doctor, David Sheinbaum (Jean Reno), who struggles to minister to the deportees' needs, and a non-Jewish nurse, Annette Monod (Mélanie Laurent from Inglourious Basterds), who accompanies them in their transit-camp ordeal.

Written as well as directed by Bosch (who scripted Ridley Scott's 1492: Conquest of Paradise), the movie is set at a high emotional pitch that fails to disguise the fact that it is overdocumented and underdramatized. La Rafle is history by numbers, ticking off key events as they occur and inserting gobbets of factual information—none new or revelatory—into the narrative.

The characters are two-dimensional and the cast is required to do little more than emote and express high-minded sentiments of one form or another. Historical context is provided by scenes representing Hitler at his Eagle's Nest in Berchtesgaden or the Vichy prime minister Pierre Laval signing off on the deportations.

In its earnestness, the film strikes too many false notes, often undermining scenes intended to carry an intense emotional charge, most notably the separation of the Jewish children from their parents. But perhaps its greatest failing, and the main source of the unease that the film arouses, is its determination to let the French population at large off the hook. With a single exception (a blowsy baker's wife), the people of Paris are shown as doing their noble best to foil or hinder the operation—an entirely dubious proposition—and a closing title adds a self-congratulatory note.

A bankable cast, a hint of controversy and high production values may play in their favor commercially, but Bosch and her producer-husband Ilan Goldman have come dangerously close to making a feel-good movie about the Holocaust.
The Hollywood Reporter
Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Author: 
Rate This Article: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
 

More Specialty Releases

PK
Film Review: PK

An alien trying to return home tangles with religious authorities in a low-key Bollywood message drama. More »

A Small Section
Film Review: A Small Section of the World

Worthy but uninvolving documentary about the coffee-producing women of Costa Rica. More »

Sagrada
Film Review: Sagrada: The Mystery of Creation

The fabulous 130-year work-in-progress that is Barcelona's Sagrada Familia cathedral, as well as its crazy-brilliant originator, Antonio Gaudi, is the focus of this vividly informative documentary. More »

Inside the Mind of Leonardo
Film Review: Inside the Mind of Leonardo in 3D

Documentary-feature hybrid that offers unexpected insight into the world of Leonardo da Vinci, but nonetheless suffers from a heavy hand and pretentious sensibility. More »

ADVERTISEMENT



REVIEWS

Into the Woods
Film Review: Into the Woods

Over-scaled, too dark and only intermittently charming Sondheim musical adaptation does a disservice to a great cast and is often so noisy you can't even appreciate the music. More »

The H obbit: The Battle of the Five Armies
Film Review: The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies

After rewriting the rules for modern fantasy cinema, for the better and worse, Peter Jackson’s six-film Tolkien saga slams, bangs and shudders to a long-overdue conclusion. More »

Player for the Film Journal International website.


ADVERTISEMENT



INDUSTRY GUIDES

» Blue Sheets
FJI's guide to upcoming movie releases, including films in production and development. Check back weekly for the latest additions.

» Distribution Guide
» Equipment Guide
» Exhibition Guide

ORDER A PRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Film Journal International

Subscribe to the monthly print edition of Film Journal International and get the full visual impact of this valuable resource for the cinema business.

» Click Here

SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES

Learn how to promote your company at the Film Expo Group events: ShowEast, CineEurope, and CineAsia.

» Click Here