-By Frank Lovece
For movie details, please click here.
There are moments, early on, when you wish political scientist and
first-time documentary filmmaker Fredrik Stanton had interviewed
government and police authorities to get their side of the story
regarding the populist uprising that drove Egyptian dictator Hosni
Mubarek out of office in February 2011. But then comes the footage
from this first "Facebook revolution," cell-phone video showing
police thrashing unarmed demonstrators, and you realize any cursory
attempt at balance would simply recall the old joke, "And so, Mr.
Hitler, how do you respond to these charges?" When official figures
themselves show at least 846 civilians dead and some 6,000 injured,
any proffered rationale would have been, let's say,
insufficient.
The hindsight of history shows it's hardly hyperbole to describe
this sorry climax of Mubarek's 30-year rule as evil. Hani
Shukrallah, managing editor of
Ah-Ahram, Egypt's largest
newspaper, cites the government's multi-billion-dollar corruption
when the largely impoverished populace could barely afford food:
The protestors' chant of "Bread, freedom, human dignity" was
literal.
Uprising does skim through the reasons Mubarek
retained a state of emergency from 1981 on—a choice that, says
Human Rights Watch's Heba Morayef, "allowed the Ministry of
Interior to detain thousands of people without charge or trial for
unlimited periods of time." Police would torture political
prisoners. And as former U.S. ambassador Edward Walker says, his
office would write a yearly report detailing human-rights abuses,
"hand it over to the Ministry of Interior and to the presidency,
and they said, 'Oh, we'll do better.' Then next year we did it all
over again." Of countenancing the relatively stable American ally
for so long, Walker admits, "We took steps which today I wish we
hadn't. I can't say I wasn't part of it. But we didn't anticipate
that it would go as far as it did."
The documentary—which scored an admirable array of American
officials, protest leaders, scholars and others yet keeps returning
to video of street protests with the regularity of a
refrain—introduces us to Esraa Abdel Fattah, aka "Facebook Girl,"
and other co-founders of 2008's "April 6 Youth Movement," a protest
strike that served as a precursor to the 2011 uprising by showing
how social media could foment rebellion. She and others—both
head-scarved traditionalist women and more Westernized youth such
as blogger-activist Gigi Ibrahim—would eventually use Facebook to
organize the crucial Jan. 25, 2011 protest. As Professor Rasha
Abdulla, chair of Journalism and Mass Communication at the American
University in Cairo, marvels, "This is the first revolution in the
world that was on Facebook as an event 12 days before it happened.
People were clicking, 'I am attending the revolution'!"
"We decided we wouldn't stop until we removed Mubarek's regime,"
says the traditionalist, utterly hausfrau-ish Asmaa Mahfouz,
another "April 6" co-founder—a grand statement all the more amazing
because it came true.
Words can do little justice to the centerpiece of the documentary,
the you-are-there footage—both amateur video and from professional
photojournalists—placing you directly amid police beatings and
killings. Maybe the word "astonishing" will do. Maybe
"sick-making." Obviously, any documentary's footage is
cherry-picked for effect, but it's hard to say that teargas, water
cannons, police batons or armored vehicles that heedlessly run over
unarmed protestors at high speed can ever be exaggerated. And if
the images alone don't shock you, consider the words of Shaima
El-Elaimy, as her voice cracks and she tears up saying, "The man
standing right next to me, he got shot in the head. And his head
exploded all over me. I have no idea what they shot him with. Brain
matter was all over me. Blood." She was shot in the back herself
moments later but survived.
The documentary, completed in mid-2012, ends with the sentence "The
struggle for full democracy in Egypt continues." As of early 2013,
with Islamist Mohammed Morsi showing all indications of being
Mubarek redux, the story is still unfolding.
Film Review: Uprising
Powerful, ground-level documentary on the 2011 Egyptian revolution.
Jan 10, 2013
-By Frank Lovece
For movie details, please click here.
There are moments, early on, when you wish political scientist and first-time documentary filmmaker Fredrik Stanton had interviewed government and police authorities to get their side of the story regarding the populist uprising that drove Egyptian dictator Hosni Mubarek out of office in February 2011. But then comes the footage from this first "Facebook revolution," cell-phone video showing police thrashing unarmed demonstrators, and you realize any cursory attempt at balance would simply recall the old joke, "And so, Mr. Hitler, how do you respond to these charges?" When official figures themselves show at least 846 civilians dead and some 6,000 injured, any proffered rationale would have been, let's say, insufficient.
The hindsight of history shows it's hardly hyperbole to describe this sorry climax of Mubarek's 30-year rule as evil. Hani Shukrallah, managing editor of
Ah-Ahram, Egypt's largest newspaper, cites the government's multi-billion-dollar corruption when the largely impoverished populace could barely afford food: The protestors' chant of "Bread, freedom, human dignity" was literal.
Uprising does skim through the reasons Mubarek retained a state of emergency from 1981 on—a choice that, says Human Rights Watch's Heba Morayef, "allowed the Ministry of Interior to detain thousands of people without charge or trial for unlimited periods of time." Police would torture political prisoners. And as former U.S. ambassador Edward Walker says, his office would write a yearly report detailing human-rights abuses, "hand it over to the Ministry of Interior and to the presidency, and they said, 'Oh, we'll do better.' Then next year we did it all over again." Of countenancing the relatively stable American ally for so long, Walker admits, "We took steps which today I wish we hadn't. I can't say I wasn't part of it. But we didn't anticipate that it would go as far as it did."
The documentary—which scored an admirable array of American officials, protest leaders, scholars and others yet keeps returning to video of street protests with the regularity of a refrain—introduces us to Esraa Abdel Fattah, aka "Facebook Girl," and other co-founders of 2008's "April 6 Youth Movement," a protest strike that served as a precursor to the 2011 uprising by showing how social media could foment rebellion. She and others—both head-scarved traditionalist women and more Westernized youth such as blogger-activist Gigi Ibrahim—would eventually use Facebook to organize the crucial Jan. 25, 2011 protest. As Professor Rasha Abdulla, chair of Journalism and Mass Communication at the American University in Cairo, marvels, "This is the first revolution in the world that was on Facebook as an event 12 days before it happened. People were clicking, 'I am attending the revolution'!"
"We decided we wouldn't stop until we removed Mubarek's regime," says the traditionalist, utterly hausfrau-ish Asmaa Mahfouz, another "April 6" co-founder—a grand statement all the more amazing because it came true.
Words can do little justice to the centerpiece of the documentary, the you-are-there footage—both amateur video and from professional photojournalists—placing you directly amid police beatings and killings. Maybe the word "astonishing" will do. Maybe "sick-making." Obviously, any documentary's footage is cherry-picked for effect, but it's hard to say that teargas, water cannons, police batons or armored vehicles that heedlessly run over unarmed protestors at high speed can ever be exaggerated. And if the images alone don't shock you, consider the words of Shaima El-Elaimy, as her voice cracks and she tears up saying, "The man standing right next to me, he got shot in the head. And his head exploded all over me. I have no idea what they shot him with. Brain matter was all over me. Blood." She was shot in the back herself moments later but survived.
The documentary, completed in mid-2012, ends with the sentence "The struggle for full democracy in Egypt continues." As of early 2013, with Islamist Mohammed Morsi showing all indications of being Mubarek redux, the story is still unfolding.