-By Peter Brunette
For movie details, please click here.
Norway weighs in with its version of World War II in
Max
Manus, finally getting to honor its own resistance
heroes.
The film takes its title from the name of the gutsiest and most
colorful—if not necessarily the most important—figure in the
clandestine movement against the Nazis. Since the Germans overran
Norway in two embarrassingly short months, spawning a
collaborationist government that gave the word "Quisling" to the
world (he was the head of the government), it's good to hear about
the brave anti-Nazi Norwegians who risked life and limb for five
long years against the invaders.
That said, much of the film remains pretty standard-issue partisan
boilerplate: enthusiastic and foolhardy amateurs for whom war is a
game, followed by lots and lots of operations and gun battles as
the Nazis become increasingly panicky, ending in a final victory
tinged with disillusionment. What
Manus has going for it is
two things: the almost Hollywood-level slickness of its high
production values, which always keep the action scenes interesting
(if repetitive), and the profound depth of Max's despondency at the
end of the film, when he finally takes a respite from his nonstop
bravado to realize all his buddies are dead.
Not surprisingly, box-office receipts in Norway were enormous, and
it's only natural that prospects elsewhere will necessarily be much
more modest. Still, it's a handsome big-budget production with lots
of suspense and excitement.
Max Manus (played by Aksel Hennie, one of Norway's best-known
actors) gets his initial training fighting as a volunteer against
the Russians in Finland, and the hand-to-hand brutality of the
snow-filled combat haunts him throughout the film. After the Nazi
Blitzkrieg quickly defeats Norwegian forces, Max joins the "Oslo
Group," patriots ashamed of their country's quick surrender who
specialize in blowing up high-value Nazi targets in the Oslo
harbor. Co-directors Espen Sandberg and Joachim Roenning throw in
the obligatory love interest, but it works because its rough,
atypical contours don't run very smoothly. By the end, Max is an
alcoholic whose nerves are shattered; nevertheless, as we would
expect in a film like this, a faint smile finally shows on his face
as he rides in the victory parade with the king.
The film is always engaging, from the boyish horseplay of the young
innocents to the bravado shown in multiple encounters to the
involvement of the revered king in exile to the final toll taken by
the increasingly ruthless Nazis. An intriguing debate that
structures the film is the efficacy of fighting the Nazis with
propaganda, to win over the populace, versus direct attacks that
inevitably get a lot of civilians killed. Specific Nazi villains,
the kind who line up innocent civilians and execute them in
reprisal for "terrorist" acts, nicely punctuate the proceedings, as
do lovely shots of a picturesque Scotland, where they train for
their first mission. None of this is new, but it works.
-
The Hollywood Reporter
Film Review: Max Manus
Solid and convincing, if pedestrian, World War II story that has its moments.
Sept 2, 2010
-By Peter Brunette
For movie details, please click here.
Norway weighs in with its version of World War II in
Max Manus, finally getting to honor its own resistance heroes.
The film takes its title from the name of the gutsiest and most colorful—if not necessarily the most important—figure in the clandestine movement against the Nazis. Since the Germans overran Norway in two embarrassingly short months, spawning a collaborationist government that gave the word "Quisling" to the world (he was the head of the government), it's good to hear about the brave anti-Nazi Norwegians who risked life and limb for five long years against the invaders.
That said, much of the film remains pretty standard-issue partisan boilerplate: enthusiastic and foolhardy amateurs for whom war is a game, followed by lots and lots of operations and gun battles as the Nazis become increasingly panicky, ending in a final victory tinged with disillusionment. What
Manus has going for it is two things: the almost Hollywood-level slickness of its high production values, which always keep the action scenes interesting (if repetitive), and the profound depth of Max's despondency at the end of the film, when he finally takes a respite from his nonstop bravado to realize all his buddies are dead.
Not surprisingly, box-office receipts in Norway were enormous, and it's only natural that prospects elsewhere will necessarily be much more modest. Still, it's a handsome big-budget production with lots of suspense and excitement.
Max Manus (played by Aksel Hennie, one of Norway's best-known actors) gets his initial training fighting as a volunteer against the Russians in Finland, and the hand-to-hand brutality of the snow-filled combat haunts him throughout the film. After the Nazi Blitzkrieg quickly defeats Norwegian forces, Max joins the "Oslo Group," patriots ashamed of their country's quick surrender who specialize in blowing up high-value Nazi targets in the Oslo harbor. Co-directors Espen Sandberg and Joachim Roenning throw in the obligatory love interest, but it works because its rough, atypical contours don't run very smoothly. By the end, Max is an alcoholic whose nerves are shattered; nevertheless, as we would expect in a film like this, a faint smile finally shows on his face as he rides in the victory parade with the king.
The film is always engaging, from the boyish horseplay of the young innocents to the bravado shown in multiple encounters to the involvement of the revered king in exile to the final toll taken by the increasingly ruthless Nazis. An intriguing debate that structures the film is the efficacy of fighting the Nazis with propaganda, to win over the populace, versus direct attacks that inevitably get a lot of civilians killed. Specific Nazi villains, the kind who line up innocent civilians and execute them in reprisal for "terrorist" acts, nicely punctuate the proceedings, as do lovely shots of a picturesque Scotland, where they train for their first mission. None of this is new, but it works.
-
The Hollywood Reporter