-By Frank Lovece
For movie details, please click here.
After an abominable opening sequence, with a fast-talking narrator
spewing a parade of so many names and interlocking relationships
you need a scorecard, the sprawling Hindi political drama
Raajneeti (literally, "Politics," contextually, "Affairs of
State") squanders whatever high-minded notions it originally may
have had and devolves into a pulpy potboiler—parliament elections
by way of
The Godfather. Blatantly: One character awakens
not with a bloody horse's head in his bed, but his bloody gay
lover. The Michael Corleone character, complete with WASP
girlfriend, tries to get out but gets pulled back in, and sees his
heir-apparent brother killed at his car by the family's rivals. One
character even paraphrases a signature line from
The Godfather
Part II, instructing, "This is politics. Here, keep your enemy
close to you."
This might certainly play well in India, where the admittedly
Godfather-inspired
Sarkar (2005) was a critical and
commercial hit. But the highly specific milieu of Indian
parliamentary elections carries a resonance that's lost on
mainstream U.S. audiences—who, as well, hear the term "Bollywood"
and expect musical sequences.
Raajneeti being in no way a
musical, the only big chorus-dance number, taking place
naturalistically at a nightclub, gets as truncated as those
expectations. The film is also a modern-day telling of the ancient
epic poem
Mahabharata, further cementing its Indian
sensibilities and diminishing its American cinema viability.
To be fair, so does its wild potboiler of a story. A young woman
(Nikhila Trikha), 27 years ago, had an out-of-wedlock baby with a
leftist leader we hear no more about. The baby is put, Moses-like,
into a basket on the river by the woman's brother, Brij Gopal (Nana
Patekar), a political power-behind-the-throne in a region of the
country that’s unclear here. The child grows up to be the
charismatic Sooraj (action star Ajay Devgan, seen here in 2007's
Cash and 2008's
U Me aur Hum), who wants to run for election to
represent the lower castes. Ah, it's our movie's hero! Whoops, no,
just one of a tangled cast of characters whose story arcs virtually
all end badly if they even make it to the end of the film.
As succinctly as possible: Political party leader Bhanu Pratap
(Jehangir Khan) suffers a stroke and hands power to his younger
brother, Chandra (Chetan Pandit), and Chandra's son, Prithvi (Arjun
Rampal). This enrages Bhanu's scheming son, the villainously
mustached Veerendra (Majoj Bajpai), who recruits Sooraj to help
shore up his uncertain power base. Meanwhile, Prithvi's younger
brother, visiting American Ph.D. candidate Samar (Ranbir Kapoor,
star of 2009's terrific
Rocket Singh: Salesman of the Year) must stay in India
after Veerendra has Chandra killed. Rich party girl Irdu (Katrina
Kaif) must marry Prithvi instead of Samar, whom she loves but who
doesn't love her, and car bombs go off, and a crooked police chief
get beaten to death with a baseball bat, and the three main women
characters each get pregnant after having sex once …it all
eventually becomes so ridiculous and over-the-top violent that
there is nobody, nobody, to root for. By the end, you're almost
rooting for the villainous Veerendra simply because all the nominal
good guys turn out to be even worse.
Played too straight to enjoy as satire, too seriously to enjoy as
campy fun and too insularly Indian to mean anything to Americans,
Raajneeti at least has a historical distinction of having
some of Bollywood's most graphic sex scenes—which is to say, not
very.
Film Review: Raajneeti
More pulpy than political, this Godfather-ripoff Hindi electoral drama is a candidate for oblivion in U.S. theatres.
June 7, 2010
-By Frank Lovece
For movie details, please click here.
After an abominable opening sequence, with a fast-talking narrator spewing a parade of so many names and interlocking relationships you need a scorecard, the sprawling Hindi political drama
Raajneeti (literally, "Politics," contextually, "Affairs of State") squanders whatever high-minded notions it originally may have had and devolves into a pulpy potboiler—parliament elections by way of
The Godfather. Blatantly: One character awakens not with a bloody horse's head in his bed, but his bloody gay lover. The Michael Corleone character, complete with WASP girlfriend, tries to get out but gets pulled back in, and sees his heir-apparent brother killed at his car by the family's rivals. One character even paraphrases a signature line from
The Godfather Part II, instructing, "This is politics. Here, keep your enemy close to you."
This might certainly play well in India, where the admittedly
Godfather-inspired
Sarkar (2005) was a critical and commercial hit. But the highly specific milieu of Indian parliamentary elections carries a resonance that's lost on mainstream U.S. audiences—who, as well, hear the term "Bollywood" and expect musical sequences.
Raajneeti being in no way a musical, the only big chorus-dance number, taking place naturalistically at a nightclub, gets as truncated as those expectations. The film is also a modern-day telling of the ancient epic poem
Mahabharata, further cementing its Indian sensibilities and diminishing its American cinema viability.
To be fair, so does its wild potboiler of a story. A young woman (Nikhila Trikha), 27 years ago, had an out-of-wedlock baby with a leftist leader we hear no more about. The baby is put, Moses-like, into a basket on the river by the woman's brother, Brij Gopal (Nana Patekar), a political power-behind-the-throne in a region of the country that’s unclear here. The child grows up to be the charismatic Sooraj (action star Ajay Devgan, seen here in 2007's
Cash and 2008's
U Me aur Hum), who wants to run for election to represent the lower castes. Ah, it's our movie's hero! Whoops, no, just one of a tangled cast of characters whose story arcs virtually all end badly if they even make it to the end of the film.
As succinctly as possible: Political party leader Bhanu Pratap (Jehangir Khan) suffers a stroke and hands power to his younger brother, Chandra (Chetan Pandit), and Chandra's son, Prithvi (Arjun Rampal). This enrages Bhanu's scheming son, the villainously mustached Veerendra (Majoj Bajpai), who recruits Sooraj to help shore up his uncertain power base. Meanwhile, Prithvi's younger brother, visiting American Ph.D. candidate Samar (Ranbir Kapoor, star of 2009's terrific
Rocket Singh: Salesman of the Year) must stay in India after Veerendra has Chandra killed. Rich party girl Irdu (Katrina Kaif) must marry Prithvi instead of Samar, whom she loves but who doesn't love her, and car bombs go off, and a crooked police chief get beaten to death with a baseball bat, and the three main women characters each get pregnant after having sex once …it all eventually becomes so ridiculous and over-the-top violent that there is nobody, nobody, to root for. By the end, you're almost rooting for the villainous Veerendra simply because all the nominal good guys turn out to be even worse.
Played too straight to enjoy as satire, too seriously to enjoy as campy fun and too insularly Indian to mean anything to Americans,
Raajneeti at least has a historical distinction of having some of Bollywood's most graphic sex scenes—which is to say, not very.