Reviews - Specialty Releases


Film Review: We Are What We Are

Cannibal movie is well-cooked but hard to swallow.

Feb 17, 2011

-By Eric Monder


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1213048-We_Are_What_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

We Are What We Are has already received glowing reviews for having a sociopolitical message within its Grand Guignol trappings, but apart from the above-average production values, Jorge Michel Grau’s film disappoints as entertainment. Viewers are likely to have mixed reactions.

In Grau’s story, the patriarch of a cannibalistic clan dies suddenly, forcing his family to select a new leader to find fresh victims. While the mother, Patricia (Carmen Beato), stays in secluded mourning, the three children carry on the job. The daughter, Sabina (Paulina Gaitan), anoints her brother, Alfredo (Francisco Barreiro), family leader; younger brother Julian (Alan Chavez) barely protests, but when Patricia finds out, she is furious, assuming Alfredo is incompetent.

Sure enough, Alfredo nearly bungles his first kidnapping of a prostitute he and his family will eventually kill and eat. Later, he has difficulty chasing after a gay man and, to complicate matters, becomes attracted to his new prey. When he gets the man home, Alfredo upsets Julian by revealing his own homosexuality. Escaping, the gay man contacts the police.

Grau’s liberal, humanistic statement emerges early on about Mexican poverty and how it forces unsavory choices upon otherwise good people. Not only is this lower-class family dependent upon a sickening criminal act, many young Mexican women find their way into dangerous streetwalking and even the police look for ways to gain fame or profit off their investigations. Grau asks: In a society so full of corruption and inequity, where the wealthy metaphorically “eat” the poor, is cannibalism all that bad or hard to fathom?

For a feature director new on the scene, Grau has crafted his film well, from its darkly lit cinematography and convincingly grubby interior design to its unobtrusive musical score and simple editing and special effects. (The ritual murder scenes are low-key and relatively discreet in their goriness, though maybe too low-key and discreet to please most horror fans.)

Where Grau fails badly is with his screenplay. The story of the family’s cannibal activity contains few interesting twists or turns once the basic situation is established. There are also several lingering questions. Why do we never see the cannibalism itself, only the killings? What is the significance of the often-referenced rituals surrounding the killings—especially since they don’t appear to be the same each time? Why is Alfredo made leader when mother and daughter are clearly tougher types? Many moments don’t ring true in the context of all the kitchen-sink realism.

Perhaps more ruinous is the film’s sheer lack of humor or suspense—surprising given the subject matter. The title might be a sly reference to the saying, “We are what we eat,” but otherwise, Grau shows little sense of fun, not even the dark kind of Buñuel-inspired wit one would expect.

We Are What We Are deserves credit for revealing social problems as the subtext of a horror pic, but its filmmakers have either forgotten or never knew that a deadly serious approach, coupled with weak writing, will severely limit the pleasures of any genre.


Film Review: We Are What We Are

Cannibal movie is well-cooked but hard to swallow.

Feb 17, 2011

-By Eric Monder


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1213048-We_Are_What_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

We Are What We Are has already received glowing reviews for having a sociopolitical message within its Grand Guignol trappings, but apart from the above-average production values, Jorge Michel Grau’s film disappoints as entertainment. Viewers are likely to have mixed reactions.

In Grau’s story, the patriarch of a cannibalistic clan dies suddenly, forcing his family to select a new leader to find fresh victims. While the mother, Patricia (Carmen Beato), stays in secluded mourning, the three children carry on the job. The daughter, Sabina (Paulina Gaitan), anoints her brother, Alfredo (Francisco Barreiro), family leader; younger brother Julian (Alan Chavez) barely protests, but when Patricia finds out, she is furious, assuming Alfredo is incompetent.

Sure enough, Alfredo nearly bungles his first kidnapping of a prostitute he and his family will eventually kill and eat. Later, he has difficulty chasing after a gay man and, to complicate matters, becomes attracted to his new prey. When he gets the man home, Alfredo upsets Julian by revealing his own homosexuality. Escaping, the gay man contacts the police.

Grau’s liberal, humanistic statement emerges early on about Mexican poverty and how it forces unsavory choices upon otherwise good people. Not only is this lower-class family dependent upon a sickening criminal act, many young Mexican women find their way into dangerous streetwalking and even the police look for ways to gain fame or profit off their investigations. Grau asks: In a society so full of corruption and inequity, where the wealthy metaphorically “eat” the poor, is cannibalism all that bad or hard to fathom?

For a feature director new on the scene, Grau has crafted his film well, from its darkly lit cinematography and convincingly grubby interior design to its unobtrusive musical score and simple editing and special effects. (The ritual murder scenes are low-key and relatively discreet in their goriness, though maybe too low-key and discreet to please most horror fans.)

Where Grau fails badly is with his screenplay. The story of the family’s cannibal activity contains few interesting twists or turns once the basic situation is established. There are also several lingering questions. Why do we never see the cannibalism itself, only the killings? What is the significance of the often-referenced rituals surrounding the killings—especially since they don’t appear to be the same each time? Why is Alfredo made leader when mother and daughter are clearly tougher types? Many moments don’t ring true in the context of all the kitchen-sink realism.

Perhaps more ruinous is the film’s sheer lack of humor or suspense—surprising given the subject matter. The title might be a sly reference to the saying, “We are what we eat,” but otherwise, Grau shows little sense of fun, not even the dark kind of Buñuel-inspired wit one would expect.

We Are What We Are deserves credit for revealing social problems as the subtext of a horror pic, but its filmmakers have either forgotten or never knew that a deadly serious approach, coupled with weak writing, will severely limit the pleasures of any genre.
Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Author: 
Rate This Article: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
 

More Specialty Releases

The Devils Violinist
Film Review: The Devil's Violinist

The latest classical-music legend to have his life trashed–again—by a cheaply sensationalistic movie, this famed fiddler deserved way better. More »

Backstreet Boys
Film Review: Backstreet Boys: Show 'Em What You're Made Of

The ’90s boy band dusts itself off for a self-congratulatory, and not especially revelatory, career retrospective on the occasion of their 20th anniversary tour. More »

Oscar Nominated Documentary Shorts 2015
Film Review: The Oscar Nominated Short Films 2015: Documentary

The long shadow and in-your-face reality of mortality shadows nearly all the entries in this year’s powerful, draining Oscar-nominated documentary short films program. More »

Film Review: The Oscar Nominated Short Films 2015: Live- Action

This year’s program of Oscar-nominated live-action short films is longer on character and short on cute. More »

ADVERTISEMENT



REVIEWS

Project Almanac
Film Review: Project Almanac

Saying this underbaked Chronicle knockoff is meant for teenagers is an insult to the intelligence of teenagers everywhere. More »

The Wedding Ringer
Film Review: The Wedding Ringer

Intermittently amusing bro-comedy trifle that confirms Kevin Hart's talent, though not his taste in material. More »

Player for the Film Journal International website.


ADVERTISEMENT



INDUSTRY GUIDES

» Blue Sheets
FJI's guide to upcoming movie releases, including films in production and development. Check back weekly for the latest additions.

» Distribution Guide
» Equipment Guide
» Exhibition Guide

ORDER A PRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Film Journal International

Subscribe to the monthly print edition of Film Journal International and get the full visual impact of this valuable resource for the cinema business.

» Click Here

SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES

Learn how to promote your company at the Film Expo Group events: ShowEast, CineEurope, and CineAsia.

» Click Here