Reviews - Specialty Releases


Film Review: The Vanished Empire

Bland look at rebellious teens who experience the last days of the Soviet empire.

July 9, 2009

-By Daniel Eagan


filmjournal/photos/stylus/96971-Vanished_Empire_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

A coming-of-age drama set during the waning days of Soviet rule, The Vanished Empire flirts with big themes but settles for lukewarm dramatics. Precise enough at times to feel like an autobiography, the film overall never rises above recycling bits from better movies. While it may have been received more favorably in Russia, The Vanished Empire will draw at best tiny audiences in the West.

The film's opening suggests a lighthearted comedy about the romantic adventures of three school friends, circa 1973. But the plot quickly centers on Sergey Narbekov (Alexander Lyapin), a disaffected youth who attends a state-sponsored equivalent to prep school. When he isn't tuning out classes, Sergey is intent on sharpening his image with bootleg blue jeans and rock ’n’ roll records—paid for by pawning his grandfather's antiques.

Sergey woos newcomer Lyuda Beletskaya (Lidia Milyuzina), impressing her mother with tales of his broken home. But Lyuda takes a backseat to hijinks with his friends Kostya (Ivan Kupreyenko), a diplomat's son and bassist in an amateur rock band, and Styopa (Yegor Baranovsky), a studious geek with a hidden mean streak. The three are always willing to stand up for each other in public, keeping their feuds and betrayals private.

In hindsight, Sergey is smart to dismiss school, with its enervating lectures and pointless discipline. The entire Soviet regime was beginning to totter, another reason for Sergey and his friends to smoke pot and listen to rock. Unfortunately, the film pays almost no attention to politics. Sergey hates his class on Lenin not because he disagrees with the propaganda he's being fed, but simply because he's bored. He doesn't buy bootleg records because they are critical of authority, but because he hopes they will make him look cool.

More disturbingly, Sergey's behavior goes beyond what could be expected from a callow adolescent. He treats Lyuda with contempt, despises his single mother's decisions, and views each new co-ed as a potential conquest. It's hard to sympathize with someone who never learns from his mistakes, and who does nothing to improve himself. When he is beset by melodramatic calamities, Sergey finds an outlet in archeology, in this story at least a cure for immaturity.

Director Karen Shakhnazarov stages the action in a brisk, unfussy manner, and elicits affecting performances from his young cast. (Milyuzina is especially good as the lovesick Lyuda.) The head of Mosfilm Studios and veteran of over a dozen features, Shakhnazarov may have been aiming for a Russian Graffiti by casting a rueful tinge over the story's nostalgia. But he never digs deeply enough into the material, and whether through caution or logistics, he can't find a way to expand the scope of The Vanished Empire beyond its niche focus.

The film's period details look authentic and are both charming and amusing. It's a relief to learn that teens of every generation the world over fall victim to garish clothes and cheesy pop music.
—Daniel Eagan


Film Review: The Vanished Empire

Bland look at rebellious teens who experience the last days of the Soviet empire.

July 9, 2009

-By Daniel Eagan


filmjournal/photos/stylus/96971-Vanished_Empire_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

A coming-of-age drama set during the waning days of Soviet rule, The Vanished Empire flirts with big themes but settles for lukewarm dramatics. Precise enough at times to feel like an autobiography, the film overall never rises above recycling bits from better movies. While it may have been received more favorably in Russia, The Vanished Empire will draw at best tiny audiences in the West.

The film's opening suggests a lighthearted comedy about the romantic adventures of three school friends, circa 1973. But the plot quickly centers on Sergey Narbekov (Alexander Lyapin), a disaffected youth who attends a state-sponsored equivalent to prep school. When he isn't tuning out classes, Sergey is intent on sharpening his image with bootleg blue jeans and rock ’n’ roll records—paid for by pawning his grandfather's antiques.

Sergey woos newcomer Lyuda Beletskaya (Lidia Milyuzina), impressing her mother with tales of his broken home. But Lyuda takes a backseat to hijinks with his friends Kostya (Ivan Kupreyenko), a diplomat's son and bassist in an amateur rock band, and Styopa (Yegor Baranovsky), a studious geek with a hidden mean streak. The three are always willing to stand up for each other in public, keeping their feuds and betrayals private.

In hindsight, Sergey is smart to dismiss school, with its enervating lectures and pointless discipline. The entire Soviet regime was beginning to totter, another reason for Sergey and his friends to smoke pot and listen to rock. Unfortunately, the film pays almost no attention to politics. Sergey hates his class on Lenin not because he disagrees with the propaganda he's being fed, but simply because he's bored. He doesn't buy bootleg records because they are critical of authority, but because he hopes they will make him look cool.

More disturbingly, Sergey's behavior goes beyond what could be expected from a callow adolescent. He treats Lyuda with contempt, despises his single mother's decisions, and views each new co-ed as a potential conquest. It's hard to sympathize with someone who never learns from his mistakes, and who does nothing to improve himself. When he is beset by melodramatic calamities, Sergey finds an outlet in archeology, in this story at least a cure for immaturity.

Director Karen Shakhnazarov stages the action in a brisk, unfussy manner, and elicits affecting performances from his young cast. (Milyuzina is especially good as the lovesick Lyuda.) The head of Mosfilm Studios and veteran of over a dozen features, Shakhnazarov may have been aiming for a Russian Graffiti by casting a rueful tinge over the story's nostalgia. But he never digs deeply enough into the material, and whether through caution or logistics, he can't find a way to expand the scope of The Vanished Empire beyond its niche focus.

The film's period details look authentic and are both charming and amusing. It's a relief to learn that teens of every generation the world over fall victim to garish clothes and cheesy pop music.
—Daniel Eagan
Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Author: 
Rate This Article: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
 

More Specialty Releases

Before Midnight
Film Review: Before Midnight

Nearly two decades have passed since Jesse and Celine met on that train bound for Vienna. This third chapter hits new highs as Richard Linklater gets down and dirty about the challenges of long-term commitment. More »

Frances Ha
Film Review: Frances Ha

Spot-on, exquisitely crafted portrait of a floundering 20-something. More »

State_194
Film Review: State 194

Clear-headed and utterly reasonable and engrossing doc suggesting why Israel and the Palestinians cannot finally consummate the long-talked-about, generally accepted two-state solution to Middle East antagonism. More »

English_Teacher
Film Review: The English Teacher

This theatre-centric frolic has a clever, pleasing start, but sadly degenerates into bland formula stuff. More »

ADVERTISEMENT



REVIEWS

Star Trek Into Darkness
Film Review: Star Trek Into Darkness

The post-conversion 3D is disappointing, but the newest Star Trek adventure remains exciting summer entertainment with a most appealing ensemble cast. More »

The Great Gatsby
Film Review: The Great Gatsby

Jay-Z meets Jay G in this hyperventilated version of F. Scott’s eloquent novel about an enigmatic self-made millionaire—the film isn’t for purists, but Baz should generate a buzz with young audiences. More »

Player for the Film Journal International website.


ADVERTISEMENT



INDUSTRY GUIDES

» Blue Sheets
FJI's guide to upcoming movie releases, including films in production and development. Check back weekly for the latest additions.

» Distribution Guide
» Equipment Guide
» Exhibition Guide

ORDER A PRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Film Journal International

Subscribe to the monthly print edition of Film Journal International and get the full visual impact of this valuable resource for the cinema business.

» Click Here

SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES

Learn how to promote your company at the Film Expo Group events: ShowEast, CineEurope, and CineAsia.

» Click Here