-By Eric Monder
For movie details, please click here.
Wretches & Jabberers, the off-putting title of this
documentary about two middle-aged men with autism who educate
others about their condition, does an admirable job covering the
men’s mission but emphasizes their traveling and presentations at
the expense of some other, more gripping issues.
Both hailing from Vermont, Larry Bissonnette and Tracy Thresher
advocate for people with autism across the globe: Japan, Sri Lanka,
Finland, as well as the United States. Since they have difficulty
speaking, and being understood, the duo, with the help of
assistants Pascal Cheng and Harvey Levoy, type their thoughts on a
specially designed keyboard so their their words appear on a
computer screen that can be projected for the audience to
read.
The good news about
Wretches & Jabberers is that
director Geraldine Wurzburg is both careful with and respectful of
her subjects. She focuses on the men (and a few others with autism)
as opposed to their parents, who were the center of attention in
another recent doc,
A Mother’s Courage. The camerawork and editing are above
average.
The bad news about
Wretches & Jabberers is that, once
the film establishes the significance of Bissonnette and Thresher’s
work, it has little else to offer. Wurzburg could have delved
further into the men’s backgrounds (quite impressive and
inspirational stories) or even the tragic history of people with
autism and other developmental disabilities. Discrimination is
addressed but not represented in any dramatic way. For whatever
reason, the director wants to remain in the upbeat present.
Stylistically speaking, Wurzburg does the best she can with
Bissonnette, Thresher, and others typing on their computers, but
the many scenes involving this action become repetitive and dull.
(This is not the first film to try but fail to make writing or
typing an exciting on-screen activity.) More annoying still, J.
Ralph’s musical score is excessive, cueing moods and feelings as if
the doc were a melodrama—syrupy violins one moment, cheerful kettle
drums the next, a bland rock-folk song interrupting a conversation.
(Big names on the soundtrack, including Norah Jones and Scarlett
Johannson, do not prove to be a plus.)
Wretches & Jabberers misses an opportunity to be a much
better movie than it is but it also may have harmed its chances of
being seen by a larger audience, which it probably should be.
Film Review: Wretches & Jabberers
Questionable treatment hurts otherwise important documentary on autism.
March 31, 2011
-By Eric Monder
For movie details, please click here.
Wretches & Jabberers, the off-putting title of this documentary about two middle-aged men with autism who educate others about their condition, does an admirable job covering the men’s mission but emphasizes their traveling and presentations at the expense of some other, more gripping issues.
Both hailing from Vermont, Larry Bissonnette and Tracy Thresher advocate for people with autism across the globe: Japan, Sri Lanka, Finland, as well as the United States. Since they have difficulty speaking, and being understood, the duo, with the help of assistants Pascal Cheng and Harvey Levoy, type their thoughts on a specially designed keyboard so their their words appear on a computer screen that can be projected for the audience to read.
The good news about
Wretches & Jabberers is that director Geraldine Wurzburg is both careful with and respectful of her subjects. She focuses on the men (and a few others with autism) as opposed to their parents, who were the center of attention in another recent doc,
A Mother’s Courage. The camerawork and editing are above average.
The bad news about
Wretches & Jabberers is that, once the film establishes the significance of Bissonnette and Thresher’s work, it has little else to offer. Wurzburg could have delved further into the men’s backgrounds (quite impressive and inspirational stories) or even the tragic history of people with autism and other developmental disabilities. Discrimination is addressed but not represented in any dramatic way. For whatever reason, the director wants to remain in the upbeat present.
Stylistically speaking, Wurzburg does the best she can with Bissonnette, Thresher, and others typing on their computers, but the many scenes involving this action become repetitive and dull. (This is not the first film to try but fail to make writing or typing an exciting on-screen activity.) More annoying still, J. Ralph’s musical score is excessive, cueing moods and feelings as if the doc were a melodrama—syrupy violins one moment, cheerful kettle drums the next, a bland rock-folk song interrupting a conversation. (Big names on the soundtrack, including Norah Jones and Scarlett Johannson, do not prove to be a plus.)
Wretches & Jabberers misses an opportunity to be a much better movie than it is but it also may have harmed its chances of being seen by a larger audience, which it probably should be.