Reviews - Specialty Releases


Film Review: Patagonia Rising

Although director Brian Lilla is neither a compelling storyteller nor a journalist, he presents a passionate and cogent scientific argument against Chile’s latest dam project in Patagonia Rising.

June 6, 2012

-By Maria Garcia


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1344498-Patagonia_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

In Manel Mayol’s 2005 documentary Switch Off, the filmmaker chronicles the resistance movement of the Mapuche people of Chile against the building of the Pangue Dam on the Biobio River. The dam was built by Endesa, a Spanish multinational and a subsidiary of Enel, an Italian energy company now partially owned by the Italian government. (Enel bore some responsibility for the 1963 collapse of the Vajont Dam near Venice, which killed nearly 2,000 people.) Because the Biobio had once been the dividing line between the Spanish empire and the uncolonized, indigenous lands of the Mapuche, Mayol viewed the Pangue Dam as an instance of recolonization. Today, the Mapuche pay the highest electric rates in the country. In some ways, Brian Lilla’s Patagonia Rising picks up where Mayol left off.

This documentary is also about Endesa, now disguised as HidroAysén. In 2011, the Chilean government approved the multinational’s plan to build five dams on the Baker and Pascua Rivers, home to other indigenous people with a proud ranching tradition. The project has the endorsement of Chile’s president, Harvard-educated billionaire Sebastian Piñera. According to Forbes, Piñera’s fortune grew by $200 million between 2010 and 2011, his first year in office. While Chile’s center-right coalition government, Endesa’s corporate structure and the Biobio River dam are all mentioned only fleetingly in this documentary, Lilla presents an intelligent scientific argument against damming the rivers.

The filmmaker advocates for sustainable energy sources, and plies the familiar environmental benefits of preserving the sparsely populated Patagonia region of Chile, home to both rivers. He also explains the unique riparian ecology, describing a warming trend that is melting Chile’s temperate-zone glaciers and causing the rivers to rise, a fact ignored in HidroAysén’s environmental impact studies. Lilla interviews the president of HidroAysén, and the “gauchos,” horse, cow and sheep ranchers, who are mostly against the dam, as well as businessmen who are in favor of it. Far more interesting are segments in which experts and resistance leaders from SinRepresas/Patagonia Without Dams discuss the deleterious effects of dams in general.

Other excellent sequences are ones in which researchers prove that Chile could replace the megawatts generated by the proposed dams through the placement of solar panels in the Atacama Desert. Unfortunately, Lilla often loses control of the narrative, and many interviews are long, repetitive monologues with no cohesive cross-cutting to related events, or to other interviews on the same topic. The filmmaker’s lack of cinematic technique, and his manipulative use of music—an unfortunate trend in documentary—is somewhat mitigated by his passion for the subject, and his ease with complex scientific evidence, for instance, from glaciologists who are studying the effects of global warming.

In the end, Lilla achieves his purpose, which is to convince the audience that the government of Chile is acting against the best interests of its people. In fact, according to the Chilean press, Piñera’s support of the HidroAysén project puts him and his party in opposition to the sentiments of over 70 percent of Chileans. In broader terms, Lilla echoes the call of Occupy Wall Street in his subtextual references to oligarchy, and the threat it represents to the planet. More than half the world’s rivers are clogged with dams, despite the consensus among scientists that dams should be the last resort in meeting a country’s energy needs. Patagonia Rising leads us to one startling conclusion—that dams are nothing more than international investment opportunities for the rich.


Film Review: Patagonia Rising

Although director Brian Lilla is neither a compelling storyteller nor a journalist, he presents a passionate and cogent scientific argument against Chile’s latest dam project in Patagonia Rising.

June 6, 2012

-By Maria Garcia


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1344498-Patagonia_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

In Manel Mayol’s 2005 documentary Switch Off, the filmmaker chronicles the resistance movement of the Mapuche people of Chile against the building of the Pangue Dam on the Biobio River. The dam was built by Endesa, a Spanish multinational and a subsidiary of Enel, an Italian energy company now partially owned by the Italian government. (Enel bore some responsibility for the 1963 collapse of the Vajont Dam near Venice, which killed nearly 2,000 people.) Because the Biobio had once been the dividing line between the Spanish empire and the uncolonized, indigenous lands of the Mapuche, Mayol viewed the Pangue Dam as an instance of recolonization. Today, the Mapuche pay the highest electric rates in the country. In some ways, Brian Lilla’s Patagonia Rising picks up where Mayol left off.

This documentary is also about Endesa, now disguised as HidroAysén. In 2011, the Chilean government approved the multinational’s plan to build five dams on the Baker and Pascua Rivers, home to other indigenous people with a proud ranching tradition. The project has the endorsement of Chile’s president, Harvard-educated billionaire Sebastian Piñera. According to Forbes, Piñera’s fortune grew by $200 million between 2010 and 2011, his first year in office. While Chile’s center-right coalition government, Endesa’s corporate structure and the Biobio River dam are all mentioned only fleetingly in this documentary, Lilla presents an intelligent scientific argument against damming the rivers.

The filmmaker advocates for sustainable energy sources, and plies the familiar environmental benefits of preserving the sparsely populated Patagonia region of Chile, home to both rivers. He also explains the unique riparian ecology, describing a warming trend that is melting Chile’s temperate-zone glaciers and causing the rivers to rise, a fact ignored in HidroAysén’s environmental impact studies. Lilla interviews the president of HidroAysén, and the “gauchos,” horse, cow and sheep ranchers, who are mostly against the dam, as well as businessmen who are in favor of it. Far more interesting are segments in which experts and resistance leaders from SinRepresas/Patagonia Without Dams discuss the deleterious effects of dams in general.

Other excellent sequences are ones in which researchers prove that Chile could replace the megawatts generated by the proposed dams through the placement of solar panels in the Atacama Desert. Unfortunately, Lilla often loses control of the narrative, and many interviews are long, repetitive monologues with no cohesive cross-cutting to related events, or to other interviews on the same topic. The filmmaker’s lack of cinematic technique, and his manipulative use of music—an unfortunate trend in documentary—is somewhat mitigated by his passion for the subject, and his ease with complex scientific evidence, for instance, from glaciologists who are studying the effects of global warming.

In the end, Lilla achieves his purpose, which is to convince the audience that the government of Chile is acting against the best interests of its people. In fact, according to the Chilean press, Piñera’s support of the HidroAysén project puts him and his party in opposition to the sentiments of over 70 percent of Chileans. In broader terms, Lilla echoes the call of Occupy Wall Street in his subtextual references to oligarchy, and the threat it represents to the planet. More than half the world’s rivers are clogged with dams, despite the consensus among scientists that dams should be the last resort in meeting a country’s energy needs. Patagonia Rising leads us to one startling conclusion—that dams are nothing more than international investment opportunities for the rich.
Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Author: 
Rate This Article: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
 

More Specialty Releases

Tracks
Film Review: Tracks

Ably supported by Adam Driver, Mia Wasikowska commands the screen in John Curran’s superbly photographed drama based on a true story. More »

The Zero Theorem
Film Review: The Zero Theorem

A noisy, hyperkinetic, visually gorgeous spectacle that tackles the mother of all big questions–the meaning of life—Terry Gilliam's latest is sometimes frustrating and occasionally outright goofy, but it's never dull. More »

Art and Craft
Film Review: Art and Craft

Documentary portrait of the artist as a disturbed man, but one who is overwhelmingly endearing, functioning and talented—and whose métier happens to be art forgery. This smartly produced and constructed art-themed art-house entry delivers a canvas of caper, comedy and delightful curiosities that engage and provoke some serious thought. Like the hero’s forgeries, it deserves a close look. More »

Pump
Film Review: Pump

Thought-provoking documentary about the lunacy of only fueling cars with gasoline loses credibility the more it turns into a single-minded broadside. More »

ADVERTISEMENT



REVIEWS

The Maze Runner
Film Review: The Maze Runner

Youths try to break out of a deadly maze in the latest young-adult doomsday thriller. More »

This is Where I Leave You
Film Review: This Is Where I Leave You

Siblings bond, fight and face new problems after the death of their father in an ensemble dramedy based on the best-selling novel. More »

Player for the Film Journal International website.


ADVERTISEMENT



INDUSTRY GUIDES

» Blue Sheets
FJI's guide to upcoming movie releases, including films in production and development. Check back weekly for the latest additions.

» Distribution Guide
» Equipment Guide
» Exhibition Guide

ORDER A PRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Film Journal International

Subscribe to the monthly print edition of Film Journal International and get the full visual impact of this valuable resource for the cinema business.

» Click Here

SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES

Learn how to promote your company at the Film Expo Group events: ShowEast, CineEurope, and CineAsia.

» Click Here