Reviews - Specialty Releases


Film Review: El Sicario, Room 164

A cross between a feature-length home movie and instant avant-garde classic, El Sicario, Room 164 records a man in a room (though not just any man) talking for 80 charged minutes.

Dec 27, 2011

-By Eric Monder


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1300938-El_Sicario_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

You don’t see the violence per se, but this documentary about a Mexican drug cartel hit man (a.k.a. “El Sicario”) goes way beyond the usual souped-up Hollywood caricatures of such, merely by recording the man’s testimony of past events. It is hard to imagine anyone outside the art-house set flocking to appreciate the film’s pared-down, minimalist approach, yet once viewers get in front of the screen, they won’t be moving away anytime soon.

El Sicario, Room 164 is based on a 2009 Harper’s magazine article by journalist Charles Bowden, who first interviewed the titular figure, a Ciudad Juarez hit man on the run from the law (who still today has a bounty on his head). When the article first appeared, Italian-born filmmaker Gianfranco Rosi (Below Sea Level) was so taken with it, he contacted Bowden and established enough of a rapport with “El Sicario” to convince him to talk for the first time in front of a camera.

Rosi and his crew set up the interview in a nondescript motel room located on the U.S./Mexican border and—with the condition he be disguised with a black hood—the hit man confessed to a 20-year career of brutal and deadly crimes. Throughout the film, El Sicario speaks through his dark mesh covering, mostly while seated, and depicts some of his experiences by drawing free-style on a canvas pad.

Simple, even dull, as it sounds, El Sicario, Room 164 is anything but: The contents of the transcript alone would be enough to rivet one’s attention, but the  personality of the man himself is also a major factor in the film’s success. (Clearly, El Sicario used his wiles, intellect and even charm to perform some of the less deadly acts of his business.) Just the same, our “protagonist” is also a bit ordinary at times (the banality of evil, perhaps?).

Despite the occasional nagging feeling that we are witnessing a great piece of performance art, a stunt by a filmmaker and a terrific actor (this is especially the case in the over-the-top last reel when he speaks of a religious conversion), the narrative rings authentically true enough for us to question not the primary subject of the film (or the “journalistic” coup by Rosi and Bowden), but the corrupt way Mexican (and other societies) operate by allowing an uneasy alliance between drug cartels and the police, including the governments themselves, all in a shameful quest for illegal profits. (To wit, El Sicario was on the police force when he started his life of contracted torture and murder.) In the end, the filmmakers seem to be saying, it doesn’t really matter if El Sicario represents a true person as long as he represents the Truth.

Some more astute critics have already compared El Sicario, Room 164 with the work of French director Claude Lanzmann’s Holocaust documentaries, proving that a static interview in a confined space has the potential to be just as cinematic as any high-tech Hollywood product. There could be no higher praise than that.


Film Review: El Sicario, Room 164

A cross between a feature-length home movie and instant avant-garde classic, El Sicario, Room 164 records a man in a room (though not just any man) talking for 80 charged minutes.

Dec 27, 2011

-By Eric Monder


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1300938-El_Sicario_Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

You don’t see the violence per se, but this documentary about a Mexican drug cartel hit man (a.k.a. “El Sicario”) goes way beyond the usual souped-up Hollywood caricatures of such, merely by recording the man’s testimony of past events. It is hard to imagine anyone outside the art-house set flocking to appreciate the film’s pared-down, minimalist approach, yet once viewers get in front of the screen, they won’t be moving away anytime soon.

El Sicario, Room 164 is based on a 2009 Harper’s magazine article by journalist Charles Bowden, who first interviewed the titular figure, a Ciudad Juarez hit man on the run from the law (who still today has a bounty on his head). When the article first appeared, Italian-born filmmaker Gianfranco Rosi (Below Sea Level) was so taken with it, he contacted Bowden and established enough of a rapport with “El Sicario” to convince him to talk for the first time in front of a camera.

Rosi and his crew set up the interview in a nondescript motel room located on the U.S./Mexican border and—with the condition he be disguised with a black hood—the hit man confessed to a 20-year career of brutal and deadly crimes. Throughout the film, El Sicario speaks through his dark mesh covering, mostly while seated, and depicts some of his experiences by drawing free-style on a canvas pad.

Simple, even dull, as it sounds, El Sicario, Room 164 is anything but: The contents of the transcript alone would be enough to rivet one’s attention, but the  personality of the man himself is also a major factor in the film’s success. (Clearly, El Sicario used his wiles, intellect and even charm to perform some of the less deadly acts of his business.) Just the same, our “protagonist” is also a bit ordinary at times (the banality of evil, perhaps?).

Despite the occasional nagging feeling that we are witnessing a great piece of performance art, a stunt by a filmmaker and a terrific actor (this is especially the case in the over-the-top last reel when he speaks of a religious conversion), the narrative rings authentically true enough for us to question not the primary subject of the film (or the “journalistic” coup by Rosi and Bowden), but the corrupt way Mexican (and other societies) operate by allowing an uneasy alliance between drug cartels and the police, including the governments themselves, all in a shameful quest for illegal profits. (To wit, El Sicario was on the police force when he started his life of contracted torture and murder.) In the end, the filmmakers seem to be saying, it doesn’t really matter if El Sicario represents a true person as long as he represents the Truth.

Some more astute critics have already compared El Sicario, Room 164 with the work of French director Claude Lanzmann’s Holocaust documentaries, proving that a static interview in a confined space has the potential to be just as cinematic as any high-tech Hollywood product. There could be no higher praise than that.
Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Author: 
Rate This Article: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
 

More Specialty Releases

The Devils Violinist
Film Review: The Devil's Violinist

The latest classical-music legend to have his life trashed–again—by a cheaply sensationalistic movie, this famed fiddler deserved way better. More »

Backstreet Boys
Film Review: Backstreet Boys: Show 'Em What You're Made Of

The ’90s boy band dusts itself off for a self-congratulatory, and not especially revelatory, career retrospective on the occasion of their 20th anniversary tour. More »

Oscar Nominated Documentary Shorts 2015
Film Review: The Oscar Nominated Short Films 2015: Documentary

The long shadow and in-your-face reality of mortality shadows nearly all the entries in this year’s powerful, draining Oscar-nominated documentary short films program. More »

Film Review: The Oscar Nominated Short Films 2015: Live- Action

This year’s program of Oscar-nominated live-action short films is longer on character and short on cute. More »

ADVERTISEMENT



REVIEWS

Project Almanac
Film Review: Project Almanac

Saying this underbaked Chronicle knockoff is meant for teenagers is an insult to the intelligence of teenagers everywhere. More »

The Wedding Ringer
Film Review: The Wedding Ringer

Intermittently amusing bro-comedy trifle that confirms Kevin Hart's talent, though not his taste in material. More »

Player for the Film Journal International website.


ADVERTISEMENT



INDUSTRY GUIDES

» Blue Sheets
FJI's guide to upcoming movie releases, including films in production and development. Check back weekly for the latest additions.

» Distribution Guide
» Equipment Guide
» Exhibition Guide

ORDER A PRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Film Journal International

Subscribe to the monthly print edition of Film Journal International and get the full visual impact of this valuable resource for the cinema business.

» Click Here

SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES

Learn how to promote your company at the Film Expo Group events: ShowEast, CineEurope, and CineAsia.

» Click Here