Reviews - Specialty Releases


Film Review: Salinger

Hyperventilating literary detective documentary about the reclusive author’s wartime traumas and perfectionist manias tells a hell of a story but gets high on its own supply.

Sept 5, 2013

-By Chris Barsanti


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1384378-Salinger-Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

Amazingly, for the first hour or so of Shane Salerno’s juicy, literary-tabloid documentary, the quality and temperament of J.D. Salinger’s writing hardly comes into it. Salerno assembles a team of biographers and writers to tell the story of the promising but rebellious Jewish-Catholic kid who was kicked out of some of the best East Coast boarding schools before turning his hand to writing. When World War II began, he was a handsome short-story writer in his early 20s dating the gorgeous young Oona O’Neill, daughter of Eugene O’Neill and former girlfriend of Orson Welles. Still photos of Salinger from the time show him as a matinee-idol writer: soulful dark eyes, trimly tailored suit, cigarette brandished like a weapon.

By 1945, O’Neill had run off and married the many-decades-older Charlie Chaplin, and Salinger was suffering a nervous breakdown after enduring nearly 300 days of combat from D-Day to the liberation of Dachau concentration camp. Salerno interviews Salinger’s buddies in his army intelligence unit (an excellent assignment for any burgeoning writer), who remember him working on The Catcher in the Rye as they slogged through the bloody northern France campaign. One of Salerno’s talking heads refers to those wartime horrors as “the ghost in the machine” that haunts Salinger’s fiction, particularly quietly explosive classics like “A Perfect Day for Bananafish.”

The postwar years are dealt with in a similar flash of activity: the deceptively cool short stories that popped up in the pages of The New Yorker one after the other, a comically off-base film adaptation of one of them, and then the bombshell that was The Catcher in the Rye in 1951. Just a couple of years after that, Salinger moved to New Hampshire, and published nothing after 1965 until his death in 2010. Glimpses of that isolated life are spotted only in interviews with friends and his troubling relationships with a number of teenage women, including interviewee Joyce Maynard, who infamously auctioned off Salinger’s love letters to her. It’s in the evocation of a war-traumatized Salinger turning into the closed-off and sometimes cruel narcissist, hiding out for weeks at a time in his famous writing bunker and ignoring his children, that the film finds its most dramatic, rewarding material.

Although Salinger contains several acute insights about the author’s psychology, its tendency to get as overly excited as the distributor’s heavily hyped publicity campaign sometimes cheapens the whole affair. It’s clearly a labor of love for Salerno, an action-film scribe ( Savages, Armageddon) who reportedly spent nine years doggedly digging up material. But he teases out bombshell fragments about the possibilities of new Salinger writings with all the subtlety of a rocket-propelled grenade and resorts to laughable recreations with an actor who looks nothing like Salinger himself.

Salerno includes one encomium after another from writers and actors like Edward Norton and Philip Seymour Hoffman about the impact of The Catcher in the Rye on them, and inserts a cringe-inducing PSA-ish segment showing teenagers the world over reading the book like some holy text. But his film never truly grapples with why this book about a grumpy 16-year-old wandering around New York still exerts such a vice-like grip on youthful readers. Even the troubling fact that the novel was claimed as inspiration by three different killers is given short shrift. Salinger is a little too busy dashing back from a gripping biographical study of Salinger’s life and work to drop in more boldface-type nuggets about Salinger the “Howard Hughes” recluse. The film is like an eager bloodhound that never manages to find the bone it’s looking for.



Film Review: Salinger

Hyperventilating literary detective documentary about the reclusive author’s wartime traumas and perfectionist manias tells a hell of a story but gets high on its own supply.

Sept 5, 2013

-By Chris Barsanti


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1384378-Salinger-Md.jpg

For movie details, please click here.

Amazingly, for the first hour or so of Shane Salerno’s juicy, literary-tabloid documentary, the quality and temperament of J.D. Salinger’s writing hardly comes into it. Salerno assembles a team of biographers and writers to tell the story of the promising but rebellious Jewish-Catholic kid who was kicked out of some of the best East Coast boarding schools before turning his hand to writing. When World War II began, he was a handsome short-story writer in his early 20s dating the gorgeous young Oona O’Neill, daughter of Eugene O’Neill and former girlfriend of Orson Welles. Still photos of Salinger from the time show him as a matinee-idol writer: soulful dark eyes, trimly tailored suit, cigarette brandished like a weapon.

By 1945, O’Neill had run off and married the many-decades-older Charlie Chaplin, and Salinger was suffering a nervous breakdown after enduring nearly 300 days of combat from D-Day to the liberation of Dachau concentration camp. Salerno interviews Salinger’s buddies in his army intelligence unit (an excellent assignment for any burgeoning writer), who remember him working on The Catcher in the Rye as they slogged through the bloody northern France campaign. One of Salerno’s talking heads refers to those wartime horrors as “the ghost in the machine” that haunts Salinger’s fiction, particularly quietly explosive classics like “A Perfect Day for Bananafish.”

The postwar years are dealt with in a similar flash of activity: the deceptively cool short stories that popped up in the pages of The New Yorker one after the other, a comically off-base film adaptation of one of them, and then the bombshell that was The Catcher in the Rye in 1951. Just a couple of years after that, Salinger moved to New Hampshire, and published nothing after 1965 until his death in 2010. Glimpses of that isolated life are spotted only in interviews with friends and his troubling relationships with a number of teenage women, including interviewee Joyce Maynard, who infamously auctioned off Salinger’s love letters to her. It’s in the evocation of a war-traumatized Salinger turning into the closed-off and sometimes cruel narcissist, hiding out for weeks at a time in his famous writing bunker and ignoring his children, that the film finds its most dramatic, rewarding material.

Although Salinger contains several acute insights about the author’s psychology, its tendency to get as overly excited as the distributor’s heavily hyped publicity campaign sometimes cheapens the whole affair. It’s clearly a labor of love for Salerno, an action-film scribe (Savages, Armageddon) who reportedly spent nine years doggedly digging up material. But he teases out bombshell fragments about the possibilities of new Salinger writings with all the subtlety of a rocket-propelled grenade and resorts to laughable recreations with an actor who looks nothing like Salinger himself.

Salerno includes one encomium after another from writers and actors like Edward Norton and Philip Seymour Hoffman about the impact of The Catcher in the Rye on them, and inserts a cringe-inducing PSA-ish segment showing teenagers the world over reading the book like some holy text. But his film never truly grapples with why this book about a grumpy 16-year-old wandering around New York still exerts such a vice-like grip on youthful readers. Even the troubling fact that the novel was claimed as inspiration by three different killers is given short shrift. Salinger is a little too busy dashing back from a gripping biographical study of Salinger’s life and work to drop in more boldface-type nuggets about Salinger the “Howard Hughes” recluse. The film is like an eager bloodhound that never manages to find the bone it’s looking for.
Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Author: 
Rate This Article: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
 

More Specialty Releases

Bicycling with Moliere
Film Review: Bicycling with Moliere

This sly, witty, charming comedic contemporary study of a fraught friendship between two actors hoping to mount a Molière classic is also a ride through France’s beautiful Ile de Ré island. More »

Locke
Film Review: Locke

Taut, disturbing and unique drama about a man racing toward his destiny, providing Tom Hardy, literally, with a vehicle to flaunt his acting chops. More »

Small Time
Film Review: Small Time

You might not buy a used car from the guys in Small Time, but you will enjoy the movie about their exploits, even their exploitations (of others). More »

Fading Gigolo
Film Review: Fading Gigolo

Some top screen talent gets lost in the silliness surrounding the amorous adventures of an unlikely gigolo and his even more unlikely pimp, with writer/director/actor John Turturro the shtupper “ho” co-starring with Woody Allen as the mercenary shtup-enabler. Yarmulkes off to Turturro’s brave but deeply ill-conceived comedic foray into Brooklyn’s Satmar Hasidic community and other alien territory. More »

ADVERTISEMENT



REVIEWS

Transcendence
Film Review: Transcendence

Johnny Depp is an idealistic researcher whose consciousness is uploaded into an artificial intelligence in this slick techno-thriller with delusions of seriousness from Christopher Nolan’s cinematographer. More »

Draft Day
Film Review: Draft Day

Pro football manager faces crises on the most important day of his career in a well-tooled vehicle for Kevin Costner. More »

Player for the Film Journal International website.


ADVERTISEMENT



INDUSTRY GUIDES

» Blue Sheets
FJI's guide to upcoming movie releases, including films in production and development. Check back weekly for the latest additions.

» Distribution Guide
» Equipment Guide
» Exhibition Guide

ORDER A PRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Film Journal International

Subscribe to the monthly print edition of Film Journal International and get the full visual impact of this valuable resource for the cinema business.

» Click Here

SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES

Learn how to promote your company at the Film Expo Group events: ShowEast, CineEurope, and CineAsia.

» Click Here