Reviews - Specialty Releases


Film Review: The Kill Team

Marine Adam Winfield goes on trial in a case in which U.S. soldiers murdered innocent Afghanis. Strong subject marred by poor narrative choices.

July 24, 2014

-By Daniel Eagan


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1404838-Kill_Team_Md.jpg
The press jumped on the story that in early 2010, U.S. troops had targeted and killed three innocent Afghan civilians. Director Dan Krauss started filming one of the participants, Adam Winfield, in 2011, after the Marine had been arrested and charged with premeditated murder. The Kill Team follows his trial.

Presumably denied access to court proceedings, Krauss focuses instead on several interviews with Winfield, who provides a chilling account of his squad in the 5th Stryker Brigade. Krauss also interviews Winfield's distraught parents Christopher and Emma, and his matter-of-fact lawyer Eric Montalvo, who urges the soldier to accept a plea of involuntary manslaughter.

The Kill Team makes the argument that Winfield shouldn't be on trial at all, but is instead a whistle blower who tried to alert authorities about his squad's crimes. Krauss recreates text messages Winfield exchanged with his father in 2010 that seem to corroborate his claims of innocence.

Concentrating on Winfield gives Krauss time to explain what happened in Afghanistan, but it also throws The Kill Team out of balance. The director does include several other interviews that present a broader picture of the incidents.

An unrepentant and casually profane Jeremy Morlock asserts, "It's not that you are a murderer, you're [just] convicted of murder." He calls Afghanistan "a paradise for warriors," and goes into detail about how squad leader Calvin Gibbs plotted killing civilians. (Gibbs cut off his victims' fingers to make a bone necklace.)

Andrew Holmes notes that he was 19 at the time of his deployment, and at first compared Afghanistan to Top Gun. Like the others, he complains that the war became boring and disappointing.

Calvin Gibbs, currently serving a life sentence, appears only in photographs. By all accounts the central figure in the killings, he could have added crucial insights into what happened. Also absent are military spokespeople who might have defended or refuted Winfield's statements.

Krauss, who also wrote, produced and photographed the documentary, can be heavy-handed. He cuts to black for emphasis within interviews, and uses too many shots of teary-eyed parents staring off into the distance. It doesn't help that the participants tend to speak in bald clichés. "I'm living a nightmare." "We're fighting for his life."

As the facts of the story emerge, The Kill Team begins to feel uncomfortably biased. Without giving too much away, Winfield wrestles with moral compromises that complicate his initial version of the incidents. And without questioning Winfield's motives, it sometimes feels like Krauss backed the wrong horse.

Taxi to the Dark Side set a high standard for documentaries about our wars in the Middle East. What's missing from The Kill Team is any attempt to come to grips with the three Afghani victims, admittedly an expensive task for a low-budget documentary.

The Kill Team should be commended for bringing attention to an ugly, sordid incident. But lurking on the edges of the story is a far more challenging documentary.

Click here for cast & crew information.


Film Review: The Kill Team

Marine Adam Winfield goes on trial in a case in which U.S. soldiers murdered innocent Afghanis. Strong subject marred by poor narrative choices.

July 24, 2014

-By Daniel Eagan


filmjournal/photos/stylus/1404838-Kill_Team_Md.jpg

The press jumped on the story that in early 2010, U.S. troops had targeted and killed three innocent Afghan civilians. Director Dan Krauss started filming one of the participants, Adam Winfield, in 2011, after the Marine had been arrested and charged with premeditated murder. The Kill Team follows his trial.

Presumably denied access to court proceedings, Krauss focuses instead on several interviews with Winfield, who provides a chilling account of his squad in the 5th Stryker Brigade. Krauss also interviews Winfield's distraught parents Christopher and Emma, and his matter-of-fact lawyer Eric Montalvo, who urges the soldier to accept a plea of involuntary manslaughter.

The Kill Team makes the argument that Winfield shouldn't be on trial at all, but is instead a whistle blower who tried to alert authorities about his squad's crimes. Krauss recreates text messages Winfield exchanged with his father in 2010 that seem to corroborate his claims of innocence.

Concentrating on Winfield gives Krauss time to explain what happened in Afghanistan, but it also throws The Kill Team out of balance. The director does include several other interviews that present a broader picture of the incidents.

An unrepentant and casually profane Jeremy Morlock asserts, "It's not that you are a murderer, you're [just] convicted of murder." He calls Afghanistan "a paradise for warriors," and goes into detail about how squad leader Calvin Gibbs plotted killing civilians. (Gibbs cut off his victims' fingers to make a bone necklace.)

Andrew Holmes notes that he was 19 at the time of his deployment, and at first compared Afghanistan to Top Gun. Like the others, he complains that the war became boring and disappointing.

Calvin Gibbs, currently serving a life sentence, appears only in photographs. By all accounts the central figure in the killings, he could have added crucial insights into what happened. Also absent are military spokespeople who might have defended or refuted Winfield's statements.

Krauss, who also wrote, produced and photographed the documentary, can be heavy-handed. He cuts to black for emphasis within interviews, and uses too many shots of teary-eyed parents staring off into the distance. It doesn't help that the participants tend to speak in bald clichés. "I'm living a nightmare." "We're fighting for his life."

As the facts of the story emerge, The Kill Team begins to feel uncomfortably biased. Without giving too much away, Winfield wrestles with moral compromises that complicate his initial version of the incidents. And without questioning Winfield's motives, it sometimes feels like Krauss backed the wrong horse.

Taxi to the Dark Side set a high standard for documentaries about our wars in the Middle East. What's missing from The Kill Team is any attempt to come to grips with the three Afghani victims, admittedly an expensive task for a low-budget documentary.

The Kill Team should be commended for bringing attention to an ugly, sordid incident. But lurking on the edges of the story is a far more challenging documentary.

Click here for cast & crew information.
Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Author: 
Rate This Article: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
 

More Specialty Releases

Laggies
Film Review: Laggies

Disappointing comedic entry about a late-20s slacker who won’t grow up is writer/filmmaker Lynn Shelton’s first outing directing someone else’s material. Points here for strong cast and an occasional chuckle, but otherwise there’s just no point. More »

Rudderless
Film Review: Rudderless

Well-done indie drama about a lost-soul house painter reborn through rock ’n’ roll is a nice actor’s showcase for star Billy Crudup and an impressive directorial debut for actor William H. Macy. But in spite of some good work onscreen, both hero and story lack the edge and originality to carry this drama beyond respectability. More »

Camp X-Ray
Film Review: Camp X-Ray

Army guard and Guantanamo detainee form a grudging relationship in a thoughtful but far-fetched drama. More »

The Tale of the Princess Kaguya
Film Review: The Tale of The Princess Kaguya

As charming as it is delicate, this unusually low-key, if a tad overlong, animated feature brings yet more prestige to the famed Ghibli output. More »

ADVERTISEMENT



REVIEWS

Fury Review
Film Review: Fury

American tanks fight superior German forces in the closing days of World War II. More »

Birdman
Film Review: Birdman (or the Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance)

Virtuosic camerawork and a stellar ensemble of actors more than make up for the occasional moment of portentous twaddle in Alejandro G. Iñárritu's latest—and maybe his best—film. More »

Player for the Film Journal International website.


ADVERTISEMENT



INDUSTRY GUIDES

» Blue Sheets
FJI's guide to upcoming movie releases, including films in production and development. Check back weekly for the latest additions.

» Distribution Guide
» Equipment Guide
» Exhibition Guide

ORDER A PRINT SUBSCRIPTION

Film Journal International

Subscribe to the monthly print edition of Film Journal International and get the full visual impact of this valuable resource for the cinema business.

» Click Here

SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES

Learn how to promote your company at the Film Expo Group events: ShowEast, CineEurope, and CineAsia.

» Click Here